Skip to main content

The Money Overview

A bank stopped $158,000 in checks in a romance scam on a 77-year-old; a Georgia man got 33 months and owes $196,500

A 77-year-old woman in western New York was told to mail two checks totaling $158,000 to pay a fine in a romance scam, and her bank detected the fraud and stopped payment before either check was cashed. The U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Western District of New York says the scheme ran from 2023 to March 2025 and reached four victims. On October 8 it announced that Stephen Odiboh, 53, of Stone Mountain, Georgia, who was convicted of conspiracy to commit wire fraud, was sentenced to 33 months in prison and ordered to pay $196,500 in restitution. The total loss and attempted loss was $356,500.

Affiliate links — we may earn a commission.

Thirty gift cards, then eight mailed checks

Prosecutors say the case began in 2023, when the woman was contacted on Facebook and came to know a man who called himself “Oliver Wilson,” who said he was a U.S. citizen and a widower living in Norway. Over about a year and a half the exchanges turned romantic. At his request she sent about 30 gift cards of $500 each, roughly $15,000, because he said he needed them to stay online.

Between January and July 2024, she mailed eight checks totaling more than $162,000 to various people and entities that “Wilson” named, according to the Western District of New York release. Two of the checks went to Odiboh. Paying third parties by mail kept the named payees one step away from the persona she believed she was dating, and each check was a separate decision made over several months.

In December 2024 “Wilson” said Norwegian customs was holding him and that he needed to pay a $158,000 fine. He directed her to mail two checks for that amount, and her bank spotted the fraud and stopped payment before they could be cashed. The Federal Trade Commission’s advice for anyone who has paid a romance scammer is to contact the gift card company, wire service or bank right away, say that a scammer was paid, and ask for a refund.

Prosecutors describe contact that began on Facebook and on dating websites, which a data broker removal does not reach. A different exposure is the personal information that sits on data broker and people-search sites, and Incogni sends removal requests to those brokers on a person’s behalf and keeps re-sending them. Less personal data on broker lists can mean fewer scam calls, texts and emails. The tool covers the broker part only and does not screen a message that arrives on social media.

Zelle, Cash App and a wire in three other cases

The release describes three more victims. In April 2024 a co-conspirator posing as “Alex Alberto” asked a caterer for services and sent an $800 deposit. The caterer then received a $2,800 check and was told to cash it and send $2,000 to Odiboh through Zelle. The caterer recognized the fraud and did not deposit the check, so the $2,000 never moved. The pattern uses a check larger than the amount owed and asks for the difference back in cash-like form.

A third victim met a co-conspirator posing as “William Rivera” on a dating website in 2024 and sent $2,000 to Odiboh through Cash App on August 14, 2024. A fourth victim met a man posing as “Alec Jonas” on a dating website in March 2025. He claimed to work in Bahrain and to need money to ship goods to Texas, and the victim wired $17,525. The release does not give the ages of the second, third or fourth victims.

Across the four victims, the payment routes were gift cards, mailed checks, Zelle, Cash App and a wire. The stopped $158,000 checks and the undeposited $2,800 check never moved money. The gift cards, the Cash App payment and the wire did.

A 33-month sentence and what restitution covers

U.S. Attorney Michael DiGiacomo announced the sentence imposed by U.S. District Judge Charles J. Siragusa. Assistant U.S. Attorney Meghan K. McGuire handled the case. The investigation was carried out by the FBI, under Special Agent-in-Charge Allen D. Davis II, and by IRS Criminal Investigation, under Special Agent-in-Charge Harry Chavis. The release does not say whether Odiboh pleaded guilty or went to trial, only that he was convicted of conspiracy to commit wire fraud.

The $196,500 restitution order is just over half of the $356,500 the office counts as total loss and attempted loss. That combined figure includes money that never left an account, such as the $158,000 in checks the bank stopped. The release does not break the restitution order down by victim, so the share owed to the 77-year-old woman is not public.

The conduct described stretches from 2023 to March 2025, and the sentence came about 19 months after the last event in the release. During that period, according to the office, Odiboh took part with co-conspirators in schemes against four people who were reached through Facebook, dating websites and a catering request. Only Odiboh’s sentence is announced here; the release does not describe charges against the people behind the personas.

Reporting a romance-scam payment

The FTC takes reports at ReportFraud.ftc.gov and also advises telling the social networking site or app where the person was met. Its page lists the payment methods romance scammers ask for as wire transfers, gift cards with the PIN codes, money transfer apps and cryptocurrency. The first call after a payment goes to the company that issued the card or moved the money, because the FTC says speed matters.

The FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center takes complaints at ic3.gov and runs an Elder Fraud Hotline at (833) 372-8311, also written 833-FRAUD-11, open Monday through Friday from 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. Eastern. For a wire transfer, the center says to ask the bank for a recall and a hold harmless letter, since acting quickly may reduce or eliminate a loss.

The largest single request in the case, $158,000, is the one that did not complete, and the release credits the victim’s bank with catching it. The money that did move went out in smaller pieces over more than a year: $15,000 in gift cards, more than $162,000 in checks, then $2,000 by Cash App and $17,525 by wire for other victims. That record is why a restitution order of $196,500 sits against a loss figure that is $160,000 higher.

The broker-list part of finding targets

Prosecutors say the first contact in this case was a Facebook message and dating-site profiles, so a broker removal is not the control that mattered there. It addresses the other half: phone numbers and addresses listed on data broker and people-search sites. Incogni sends removal requests to those sites on a person’s behalf and keeps re-sending them, and less personal data on broker lists can mean fewer scam calls, texts and emails. The status of each request shows in the account.

Put Incogni on the broker lists that carry a parent’s phone number and address →

This article was produced with AI assistance and reviewed by The Money Overview’s editorial team.