Skip to main content

The Money Overview

Arizona’s attorney general wants regulators to probe whether APS shifted about $587 million in large-user costs onto other customers

Arizona Attorney General Kris Mayes asked state utility regulators on Friday, October 9, to investigate whether a charge on Arizona Public Service bills moved about $587 million in costs tied to a few large energy users, a group her office’s release links to data centers, onto the utility’s other customers between 2023 and 2025. The request lands while APS is asking the Arizona Corporation Commission for a $608.7 million annual rate increase. The $587 million comes from an outside analysis that APS calls misleading, so it is a claim to be tested rather than a finding. Mayes wants the test run in public before any increase is approved.

No rate increase has been approved, and neither the attorney general nor APS has put a per-household dollar figure on what the request or the alleged cost shift would mean for a monthly electric bill. That leaves residential customers with a pending decision and no number to plan around. The commission, which sets APS’s rates, has not announced a hearing on the attorney general’s request, and the release lists no docket number or hearing date for an investigation. For households already stretching to cover summer cooling bills, the practical question is what help exists now while the case plays out.

APS has asked for a $608.7 million annual rate increase, and the Corporation Commission has not decided it. The Senior Property Tax & Home-Cost Relief Kit collects heating, cooling and home-repair help for older homeowners in one place.

Find heating, cooling and home-repair help for a higher APS bill in the Home-Cost Relief Kit →

What the attorney general is asking regulators to do

The attorney general’s office released the request on October 9 in a letter to Commission Chairman Nick Myers and the other commissioners. Mayes asked the commission to “swiftly and publicly investigate” whether APS’s Power Supply Adjuster facilitated what she called a nearly $600 million cost shift from large energy users to everyone else. The release does not explain how the adjuster works. It says only that the mechanism may have made the shift possible.

The letter itself makes five requests: investigate the alleged shift publicly and quickly, revisit past commission decisions if needed, order APS to hand over its underlying billing and Power Supply Adjuster records, consider requiring a full cost of service study, and make APS show with those records why the outside analysis is wrong. It cites the Arizona Constitution, which charges the commission with keeping APS rates just and reasonable, and state law giving the commission authority to reopen earlier decisions and investigate.

Where the $587 million figure comes from

The number is not the attorney general’s own. It comes from Abhay Padgaonkar, who filed a white paper titled “Mission Accomplished? Arizona’s Untested ‘Growth Pays for Growth’ Claim” in several commission dockets on October 2. 12News reported on the analysis on October 5. Padgaonkar’s conclusion is that $587 million in costs attributable to a handful of large energy users may have been allocated to other APS customers between 2023 and 2025. The attorney general’s letter does not describe his credentials or affiliation, and it says he needs APS’s underlying billing and adjuster records to verify his claims.

APS disputes the analysis. The utility called the study misleading and said it oversimplifies the Power Supply Adjuster. The commission’s executive director, Clark, also publicly disputed Padgaonkar’s conclusions, according to the attorney general’s letter. The dispute leaves two competing readings of the same charge, and the only way to settle them is the one the attorney general is asking for: APS producing the records and the calculations behind the adjuster so that regulators can compare them with the white paper.

The attorney general framed it with a conditional. “This, if true, is a textbook cost shift,” Mayes said in the release, adding that it would be a sizable one. She also pointed to what APS told a legislative committee in January 2026, when the company said, “Residential customers are not subsidizing data centers.” Her letter says the commission should not just take APS’s word for it, and that APS should show the commission and ratepayers the underlying records.

The $608.7 million rate request

APS’s request is in a separate case, docket E-01345A-25-0105, where the utility’s initial post-hearing brief, filed August 27, 2026, put the increase it is seeking at $608.7 million. Mayes’s quote in the release rounds that to $608 million a year. Her argument is that the commission should settle the cost-shift question before approving any APS increase. “Before the Commission approves any APS rate increase, Arizonans deserve answers,” she said.

The legal principle behind the request is cost causation, the idea that the customers who cause a cost should pay for it. The letter cites a 2021 ruling in Sun City Home Owners Association v. Arizona Corporation Commission, which called cost causation highly relevant to setting just and reasonable rates. It also warns that unresolved concerns could undermine public confidence in pledges that growth should pay for growth, and could erode public support for new data center development in the state.

Help with Arizona electric bills while the case is pending

APS lists several bill-help programs on its assistance programs page. Crisis Bill Assistance can provide up to $1,000 for customers in temporary hardship through partners that include Chicanos Por La Causa and Maricopa County Human Services. The Energy Support Program gives monthly discounts of up to 25% or 60% depending on household income, and up to 35% or 60% for customers who depend on electricity for life-saving medical equipment. Payment arrangements let a customer spread past-due amounts over time.

APS CARE offers up to $500 in bill assistance through The Salvation Army regardless of income, with APS matching contributions up to $500,000 from January 1 to December 31, 2026. The federal Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program, known as LIHEAP, also runs through community action agencies and local providers, and the APS page links to each program’s own application. Anyone unsure where to start can dial 211 for Arizona’s referral line.

The ruling will matter for a longer horizon. If the commission opens the inquiry Mayes wants, the first test is whether APS produces the Power Supply Adjuster records and calculations behind the $587 million question, and whether those records match the white paper or the utility’s answer. The release lists no hearing date, so the timing of any answer is open, and the $608.7 million annual request in docket E-01345A-25-0105 stays pending in the meantime.

APS is asking for $608.7 million more each year

Older households facing a possible increase have separate programs to apply to, each with its own application and renewal date. The Senior Property Tax & Home-Cost Relief Kit collects heating, cooling and home-repair help, plus an application log and renewal calendar to track each one, across 64 pages.

Track every bill-help application and renewal with the Home-Cost Relief Kit →

This article was researched and drafted with the assistance of AI and reviewed by The Money Overview editorial team.

Avatar photo

Daniel Harper

Daniel is a finance writer covering personal finance topics including budgeting, credit, and beginner investing. He began his career contributing to his Substack, where he covered consumer finance trends and practical money topics for everyday readers. Since then, he has written for a range of personal finance blogs and fintech platforms, focusing on clear, straightforward content that helps readers make more informed financial decisions.​