Skip to main content

The Money Overview

Clergy who opted out of Social Security would get a one-time chance to opt back in for 2029 or 2030 under a bill now headed to Trump

Congress has cleared H.R. 227, the Clergy Act, which would let ministers who gave up Social Security coverage reverse that choice once. The House passed it 350-5 on April 27, and the Senate passed it without changes by unanimous consent on September 30. Clergy who revoke would start paying into the system for either the first or the second tax year that begins after December 31, 2028, meaning 2029 or 2030 for most. The bill is not law yet, and its sponsor’s office said on October 1 that it was headed to the president’s desk. Under current law, the opt-out is permanent.

Where the Clergy Act stands

Representative Vince Fong, a California Republican, sponsored the bill, with Representative Mike Thompson, a California Democrat, as co-lead. The House Ways and Means Committee approved it 40-0, according to Fong’s office, before the full House passed it 350-5 under a suspension of the rules.

The Senate’s floor log for September 30 shows the bill discharged from the Finance Committee by unanimous consent and then passed without amendment the same day. No roll call was held, so no tally exists. Because the Senate changed nothing, the text that cleared the House is the text that goes to the president, and no second House vote is needed. Senator Katie Britt, an Alabama Republican, led it in the Senate.

The 2029 and 2030 revocation window

The bill text covers ministers, members of religious orders and Christian Science practitioners who hold an exemption from self-employment tax under section 1402(e)(1) of the tax code. An eligible person files an application in the form and manner the IRS Commissioner prescribes, and chooses whether the revocation starts with the first or second tax year that begins after December 31, 2028. The filing deadline is the due date of the federal income tax return, including extensions, for that second year. A calendar-year filer picking 2030 would therefore have until the 2030 return is due, in 2031.

Anyone who files late must pay the full self-employment tax that would have applied for the year the revocation covers. After revoking, a person may never again apply for the exemption. The change applies to Social Security monthly benefits based on earnings in the revocation year and later, and to the lump-sum death payment for deaths in or after that year. Fong’s office says the bill does not change the standard 10 years of contributions needed for full retired-worker benefits, which makes the start date matter for anyone close to retirement age.

For a minister in the late 50s or 60s, a 2029 start leaves a short runway against a 10-year requirement, so the benefit that opting back in builds is the real question. The Social Security Claiming & Family Benefits Kit includes a claiming calculator (Excel) for claiming age, break-even and survivor benefits, which sets a late start against the age a person claims.

Test the claiming-age break-even for a late Social Security start with the Claiming Kit →

The exemption is the reason the window exists. A Ways and Means one-page summary says exempt clergy neither pay into Social Security nor collect benefits based on their ministry work, and calls the decision to opt out irreversible. About 2,000 clergy members receive the exemption each year, according to the same summary. Congress has opened such windows before, most recently a two-year opening created in 1999 by the Ticket to Work and Work Incentives Improvement Act.

Why sponsors and groups pushed for it

Fong’s office says some pastors opted out decades ago, often on inaccurate advice, and later faced serious financial hardship. “They deserve financial security in return,” Fong said in a statement after Senate passage. Britt said clergy “should have the opportunity to enroll back in Social Security, and now they will.” Ways and Means Chairman Jason Smith said the bill would help clergy who want to rejoin “restore their participation in the system.”

Religious and retiree groups backed it as well. Michael Martin, president of the Evangelical Council for Financial Accountability, said many pastors may feel trapped by “a decision they did not fully understand.” AARP, through Jennifer Jones, its vice president for financial security, endorsed the measure because it lets clergy “opt back into earning Social Security and Medicare benefits for retirement.” The Church Alliance and GuideStone Financial Resources also endorsed it.

The bill gives the government its own task. Within 90 days of enactment, the IRS Commissioner, consulting the Social Security Commissioner, must send Congress a plan for telling eligible clergy and Christian Science practitioners they may revoke an earlier exemption. Until a signature, nothing changes for anyone who is exempt today, and no application form or filing procedure exists for the window.

Estimating what opting back in would add

The Social Security Administration’s my Social Security account is the free place to start. It offers a Social Security Statement, a way to review the earnings record for accuracy, and benefit estimates at different claiming ages. For a minister who opted out, ministry years will show no earnings credited, so the record reflects only other covered work, such as a secular job or a spouse’s record.

That earnings history sets the arithmetic. With 10 years of contributions required, a minister who revokes for 2029 could reach that mark in 2038 on ministry earnings alone, while one who picks 2030 reaches it in 2039. Credits from other covered jobs may shorten that, and the estimate shows how much the extra years would add at different claiming ages.

The choice between 2029 and 2030 is the part the bill leaves to each applicant. Starting a year later postpones the tax but also the credits, and the 90-day IRS notification plan is the first public sign of how the application will work. The text of H.R. 227 sets the window and the deadline, and the application form itself waits for the IRS.

Opting back in still needs ten years of contributions

The window brings no shortcut: Fong’s office says the standard 10-year requirement stands, so a 2029 or 2030 start decides when a retirement benefit can begin. The Social Security Claiming & Family Benefits Kit adds a claiming calculator (Excel) for claiming age, break-even and survivor benefits, built to show what waiting is worth. It runs 37 pages, with a large-print quick start.

Run the break-even on claiming ages with the Social Security Claiming Kit calculator →

This article was researched and drafted with the assistance of AI and reviewed by The Money Overview editorial team.


More in Social Security & Medicare