Florida drivers whose Star Casualty Insurance Co. total-loss claims were paid on an actual cash value basis have until October 26, 2026 to file for money the insurer is accused of leaving out. The settlement pays up to $79.85 in unpaid title and tag transfer fees, and it separately repays storage and towing charges that were taken out of the vehicle payment, plus interest. Nobody receives a check automatically. A claim form is the only route to payment, and a Miami-Dade court is set to hear on October 12 whether the deal is fair.
The class covers anyone insured under a Florida auto policy from Star Casualty between March 22, 2018 and June 26, 2026 whose first-party total-loss claim was settled on an actual cash value basis. To count, a policyholder must also have been shorted on the full title and tag fees, or had excess storage or towing charges deducted from the payment. The lawsuit, Kharevich v. Star Casualty Insurance Co., is Case No. 2023-013380-CA-01 in Miami-Dade County, and the notice carrying each person’s Claim ID and PIN went out by mail or email.
Two dates sit close together on the Star Casualty notice, the October 12 hearing and the October 26 claim deadline, and only the second one decides who gets paid. The Settlement & Refund Recovery System walks through the filing step by step so a total-loss claim is not sent in late or in the wrong form.
Walk through the Star Casualty claim form before October 26 with the System’s filing walkthrough →
What the $79.85 covers
The plaintiff, Maxim Kharevich, alleges that Star Casualty broke its own policies by failing to pay title transfer and tag transfer fees on total-loss claims. The official settlement site breaks the $79.85 into a $75.25 title fee and a $4.60 tag fee. Star Casualty denies the allegations and agreed to settle. Any amount the insurer already paid for the same fees is subtracted, so the $79.85 is a ceiling and not a flat award.
The second half of the claim is the storage and towing deduction. The settlement repays excess storage charges at up to $25 a day for as many as 8 days, a $200 maximum. A claimant who got neither fee and lost 5 days of storage would recover $79.85 plus $125, or $204.85, before interest and before any prior payments are taken off. Fees and storage together top out at $279.85 plus prejudgment interest, though the claim site headlines only the $79.85 fee figure.
Florida law already speaks to the storage side. Under section 626.9743 of the state statutes, an insurer that has been paying a vehicle’s storage must warn the policyholder before stopping and give 72 hours to move the car. The statute says nothing about title or tag fees, which is why those became the center of the class action.
The October 12 hearing and who pays the lawyers
Judge approval comes first. The fairness hearing is set for 8:30 a.m. on October 12, 2026 in a virtual courtroom, where the court will weigh whether the settlement is fair, adequate and reasonable. Class members do not have to attend. The deadlines to opt out, object or give notice of intent to speak passed on September 14, so anyone who stayed in the class is bound by the outcome and is entitled to file for the benefits.
The class lawyers are Alex R. Couch and Amy L. Judkins of Normand, Judkins & Couch in Orlando and Andrew P. Irvin of Irvin & Irvin in Winter Park. They are asking for up to $185,000 in fees and costs, and Kharevich may receive a $5,000 service award. The settlement FAQ says Star Casualty pays both on top of the claims, so neither reduces what class members receive. Class members pay no lawyer.
Money does not move on October 12. The FAQ says payments go out within 90 days of the settlement’s effective date, which depends on final approval and on any objections being resolved. A claim filed by October 26 therefore waits on the judge’s ruling and then on that clock. The site warns that the hearing date can change without notice, and the administrator’s key-dates page carries the current schedule.
Filing the claim before the October 26 cutoff
Online claims are due by 11:59 p.m. Eastern on October 26, and paper claims must be postmarked by that day. The Claim ID and PIN printed on the notice unlock the online form. A policyholder who lost the notice can email the administrator with a last name and address to get the ID, or call 1-800-290-2388. A claim goes in by mail or online, never both, and the paper form came pre-filled with the mailed notice.
Address changes matter because the check follows the address on file. The site has an Update Address page, and a name change after a marriage or divorce needs a copy of the license, decree or court order. A claim for a policyholder who has died needs a death certificate and papers such as a will showing who inherits. The administrator’s mailing address is Kharevich v Star Casualty, c/o Settlement Administrator, P.O. Box 23489, Jacksonville, FL 32241.
The class period ends June 26, 2026 and the claim window closes four months later, so recent total losses are covered along with claims from as far back as March 2018. The settlement site lists no date after October 26 for people who miss it, and it calls a claim form the only way to receive a payment.
Star Casualty claims close October 26 at 11:59 p.m. Eastern
Miss that time and a total-loss claim for up to $79.85 in title and tag fees, plus storage repayment, is gone. The Settlement & Refund Recovery System lays out the filing step by step and includes a claim log and payment tracker, so the October 26 filing date is not confused with the later date money arrives. It is a 50-page system built for open settlement claims like this one.
Log the Star Casualty claim and its payout in the System’s payment tracker →
This article was produced with AI assistance and reviewed by The Money Overview’s editorial team.