Skip to main content

The Money Overview

Starbucks plan members sent a COBRA notice from 2016 to 2023 who passed on coverage have until Dec. 2 to mail claims in a $325,000 settlement

Starbucks health plan members who were sent a COBRA notice between July 21, 2016, and Jan. 1, 2023, and did not elect continuation coverage have until Dec. 2, 2026, to mail a claim form in a $325,000 class action settlement. The fund is split pro rata among everyone who files a valid claim. Starbucks denies the allegations, and the court has not yet approved the deal.

The case is Lubin v. Starbucks Corp., No. 8:20-cv-01311, in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida in Tampa. The plaintiff alleges the COBRA notice Starbucks sent was deficient. Starbucks says the notice complied with the law, and the judge has not ruled on the merits of either side.

Who the Starbucks COBRA class covers

The class is plan participants not subject to Starbucks’ arbitration agreement, plus beneficiaries of the company’s Health and Vision plans in the United States. To be in it, a person must have been sent a COBRA notice after a qualifying event and must not have elected continuation coverage. The settlement website estimates about 33,800 people fit.

The arbitration carve-out matters. Anyone who signed Starbucks’ arbitration agreement is outside the class, so a former employee cannot assume the settlement covers them just because a letter arrived. The class definition sits in the case website’s settlement notice, and the frequently asked questions page walks through it in plain terms.

A qualifying event is the trigger that ends or reduces employer health coverage, such as a job loss, a cut in hours or a divorce. People in that spot, and spouses or children on the plan, are who the settlement describes if they let the election window pass. Those readers can match their own paperwork to the class dates, then mail a claim form postmarked by Dec. 2.

Retirement deadlines, in your inbox: Miss an enrollment or claim deadline and the money can be gone. Join the Retirement Money Brief and we’ll send you our Open Settlements & Refund Tracker as a welcome gift.

Get the Brief + the settlements tracker →

We may earn a commission from links on this page.

What a COBRA notice is supposed to say

COBRA is the federal law that lets people keep an employer’s group health plan after coverage would otherwise end, usually by paying the full premium. The U.S. Department of Labor says a group health plan must send the COBRA election notice within 44 days of a qualifying event. The department says that notice includes how to enroll.

The lawsuit says Starbucks’ notice fell short of that. According to the settlement site, the plaintiff alleges it left out required information, including how to enroll, the plan name and the plan administrator’s contact details. Starbucks denies this and maintains the notice met the law.

The notice matters because the clock is short. Under the Labor Department’s guidance, people have 60 days to elect COBRA, counted from the later of the date coverage ends or the date the notice is provided. Standard coverage lasts up to 18 months after a job loss or reduced hours, so a confusing letter can cost someone a window they never knew they had.

How much each valid claim could pay

Starbucks will pay a $325,000 gross settlement. The settlement administrator’s costs, estimated at $75,000, come out of that amount, and the remainder is the Net Settlement Fund. Every class member who submits a valid, timely claim form receives a pro rata share of that net fund.

The payout depends entirely on how many people file. The settlement FAQ gives two examples: about $30 each if 25 percent of the class files claims, and about $74 each if 10 percent do. With about 33,800 people in the class, the final figure will land somewhere along that range, and it shrinks as more people file.

Class counsel will ask the court for $450,000 in attorneys’ fees and litigation costs. Starbucks pays that amount separately, not out of the settlement fund, and the judge must approve it. The settlement site does not mention a service award for the class representative.

Money does not move right away. Payments go out only after the court grants final approval and any appeals or objections are resolved. Checks are then mailed first class within 30 days after the settlement account is funded, and recipients have 60 days from the date on the check to cash it. Unclaimed balances go to Bay Area Legal Services as a cy pres award, subject to court approval.

A mail-only claim and two other Dec. 2 dates

Claims go by U.S. Mail only. A completed form must be postmarked no later than Dec. 2, 2026, and sent to Lubin v. Starbucks Corp, c/o Settlement Administrator, P.O. Box 23309, Jacksonville, FL 32241-3309. The settlement website lists no online claim option; its online tools only update an address or name.

The deadline is a postmark date, which makes the mailing itself the risk. Anyone planning to file can mail the form well ahead of Dec. 2 and ask the post office for a receipt showing the mailing date. A form that lands in the P.O. box after Dec. 2 without a qualifying postmark is a form that does not count.

The opt-out and objection deadlines are also Dec. 2, 2026. Opting out takes a signed written request by U.S. Mail stating the case name and number, plus the person’s name, address, phone and email. An objection is filed with the court, with a copy mailed to the administrator, and must say whether the person plans to speak at the hearing.

Doing nothing carries a cost of its own. Class members who skip the claim form receive no check but are still bound by the settlement, which releases Starbucks and the other released parties from liability over the COBRA notice. Only a timely opt-out avoids that release, and opted-out members cannot present views at the hearing.

The Jan. 6 approval hearing and moving addresses

The court will decide whether the settlement is fair, reasonable and adequate at a final approval hearing on Jan. 6, 2027, at 11 a.m. in Courtroom 13A of the federal courthouse at 801 N. Florida Ave. in Tampa. Attending is optional, and class counsel represents class members there. The court may postpone the hearing or hold it by phone or Zoom, so the settlement site carries the latest word.

Because checks travel by first-class mail, the address on file decides whether a payment arrives. People who have moved since leaving Starbucks can use the update-address page on the settlement site. The approval step means the money is months away at best, which leaves time to confirm the address before any check is cut.

Got a Starbucks COBRA letter and let it lapse?

A mail-only claim with a postmark deadline is easy to lose track of, especially when the letter that put someone in the class arrived years ago. The class here runs back to July 2016, and the Dec. 2 cutoff covers the claim, the opt-out and the objection at once.

The Money Owed to You Bundle puts all eight Money Owed guides in one large-print download. Its Open Settlements: How to File guide covers the four-date rule, the two claim tiers, proof without receipts and chasing a payment, and the Claim It Checklist adds the filing checklist and a scam stop-list.

Get the open-settlements filing guide and claim checklist →

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.

Avatar photo

Daniel Harper

Daniel is a finance writer covering personal finance topics including budgeting, credit, and beginner investing. He began his career contributing to his Substack, where he covered consumer finance trends and practical money topics for everyday readers. Since then, he has written for a range of personal finance blogs and fintech platforms, focusing on clear, straightforward content that helps readers make more informed financial decisions.​


More in Smart Spending