The Internal Revenue Service has called off the October 14 public hearing on its plan to treat the refunded portion of four federal tax credits as a “Federal public benefit,” because nobody asked to speak. The Treasury Department and IRS proposal, published August 20, would cut off non-citizens who are not “qualified aliens” from the cash part of the child tax credit, the earned income credit and two others. Canceling the hearing does not change the proposal. It only means the rule moves toward final form with no oral testimony added to the file.
For taxpayers who claim any of these credits, the open question is whether the final rule will match the proposal, and nothing in the cancellation notice answers it. The IRS estimates that 24 million returns for tax year 2026 would claim a credit affected by the rule, and that between 200,000 and 700,000 taxpayers would likely become ineligible. Those estimates belong to the proposal as written, and they would change if the final regulations change the list of credits or the test for who is covered.
The IRS estimate of 200,000 to 700,000 affected taxpayers is tied to the August proposal as written and would be restated if the final regulations change it.
Get each new number in one short weekday email →
Why the October 14 hearing was canceled
The cancellation notice was published October 9 in the Federal Register, signed by Oluwafunmilayo A. Taylor, a section chief in the IRS Publications and Regulations Section. It says the hearing set for 10 a.m. Eastern on October 14 is canceled. The reason is stated in a single sentence: “We did not receive any requests to testify or outlines of topics.” The deadline for those requests was October 5.
A hearing on a proposed Treasury rule is held only if someone asks to be heard. The August notice told anyone who wanted to speak to send a request and an outline of topics by the October 5 deadline, and none arrived. Written comments on the same proposal were also due October 5, and the Federal Register page for the proposal now says comments are no longer accepted. The notice does not say how many written comments were filed.
The notice sets no date for what comes next. The IRS has not announced when final regulations will be published, and the cancellation notice contains no timetable. Questions about the hearing can go to the Publications and Regulations Section at publichearings@irs.gov, the contact the notice gives.
The four credits and the 1996 welfare law
The proposal, labeled REG-119882-25, applies a 1996 law known as the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act. That law says a non-citizen who is not a “qualified alien” is not eligible for any Federal public benefit, a term it defines to include retirement, welfare, health, disability, housing, food assistance and “any other similar benefit” paid to an individual or household by a federal agency. The IRS proposal says the refunded portion of certain credits fits that definition.
According to the August proposal in the Federal Register, the covered credits are the adoption credit, the child tax credit including its refundable portion, the American opportunity tax credit for college costs, and the earned income credit. The premium tax credit is left out because later laws address immigration status for it, and the Saver’s Match is to be handled in separate proposed regulations. Only the refunded portion would be barred, not the part that reduces tax owed.
The mechanics rest on a declaration. Eligibility would be tested on the date a taxpayer first files a return claiming the credit, and claimants would state their status under penalty of perjury on the return or a required schedule, referred to in the proposal as Schedule 3-A. On a joint return, if one spouse is a U.S. citizen, a national or a qualified alien, the other spouse would be treated as a qualified alien, so a mixed-status couple would not lose the refunded portion.
The IRS estimate of who would lose the refund
The proposal puts numbers on the change. About 49 million returns for tax year 2026 are estimated to claim at least one of the four credits, and 24 million of them would claim a credit that counts as a federal public benefit. Of the taxpayers affected, 200,000 to 700,000, or 0.8 to 2.8 percent, would likely be ineligible. The estimated disallowed credits come to $0.7 billion to $2.6 billion, based on an average benefit of $3,656.
Treasury and the IRS describe the effect as small. In the proposal’s own words, the “economic costs and benefits of the proposed regulations will be small.” For an individual household the figure is not small: the $3,656 average is what the agency counts as lost, and it is the refunded cash that would not arrive.
Timing depends on the final rule. The proposal states that the regulations would apply for taxable years ending on or after the date they are published as final regulations. No final rule has been published, and the canceled hearing is the only step announced since the comment period closed.
What happens to the proposal after the canceled hearing
The next document to watch is the final regulation, which would appear in the Federal Register under the same docket number. The August proposal remains the official statement of which credits are covered and how the test would work, and the October 9 notice gives the docket number and the IRS hearings contact.
Until a final rule is published, current law and the existing filing rules for these credits stay in force, and the proposal is not in effect. The IRS has not named a date for finishing the rule, and the cancellation notice does not either, so the first sign of change will be a Federal Register notice rather than anything on a tax form.
The IRS number to watch is the 200,000 to 700,000 range and its $3,656 average benefit. Both come from the August proposal and both would be restated if the final regulations differ from it. Treasury’s description of the economic effect as small is the position the agency took in that document, so the proposal remains the only public account of the rule’s reach.
More Financial Reading
- 24 Ways to Stretch a $2,087 Social Security Check
- 17 Places to Find Your Share of the $4.25 Billion States Give Back
- 22 Ways Retirees Can Raise $1,000 Fast Without a Job
This article was researched and drafted with the assistance of AI and reviewed by The Money Overview editorial team.