Skip to main content

The Money Overview

Amazon’s return settlement sends 92.7 percent of the net fund to shoppers who never file a claim form

Amazon’s $309.5 million return-policy settlement splits its net fund between two groups of shoppers, and the larger group has nothing to file. Settlement Subclass A holds 92.7 percent of the net fund and is paid automatically, with no claim form, while Subclass B holds the remaining 7.3 percent and must submit a claim by December 1, 2026. That reverses the usual arrangement, in which a form is the gate to a payment. In this case the gate is the subclass definition, and the settlement agreement draws that line in an unusual way.

Affiliate links — we may earn a commission.


The December 1 Subclass B form: The Settlement & Refund Recovery System includes a step-by-step filing walkthrough and a claim log and payment tracker for a form that only one of the two subclasses must file.

Open the step-by-step filing walkthrough and claim log →

A $309.5 million fund becomes a net fund before the 92.7 percent applies

The court-approved long-form notice describes the money as a $309.5 million non-reversionary common fund paid by Amazon, a structure in which unclaimed money does not flow back to the company. The 92.7 and 7.3 percent shares apply to the Net Settlement Fund rather than to that gross figure, so deductions come first. Class Counsel, the Zigler Law Group and Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan, may seek up to $100 million in attorneys’ fees and up to $1 million in cost reimbursement, and each class representative may seek a $7,500 service award.

By the writer’s arithmetic, the fee ceiling alone equals about 32 percent of the gross fund, which is why neither percentage converts into a dollar figure yet. The long-form notice describes Subclass A’s share as direct payments of the unpaid transaction amounts plus an amount proportional to potential prejudgment interest, so the payment tracks what Amazon is alleged to have failed to return. Subclass B’s 7.3 percent is reserved for members who submit claims showing it is more likely than not that they belong to that subclass and are entitled to a payment.

Timing runs well past December 1. The administrator sets the final approval hearing for March 16, 2027, at 10:00 a.m. Pacific Time in the Western District of Washington, Case No. 2:23-cv-01372-JNW, and the notice says payments are issued only after the settlement is approved and becomes final. Even Subclass A members have one task, because the notice says they must select a preferred payment method within 105 days after the court grants final approval. Never filing a claim form, in other words, is not the same as never acting.

What December 1 settles for each subclass: payment, exclusion or objection

December 1, 2026 is a single date for three different acts, according to the administrator: submitting a claim, requesting exclusion and filing an objection. The notice calls exclusion the only option that allows a person to sue, continue to sue or take part in another lawsuit against Amazon, at the price of receiving no settlement payment. Members who remain in the class release claims arising from Amazon’s actions, practices or policies related to returns, refunds and retrocharges, so staying silent is itself a decision with a legal consequence.

Objecting is a narrower step. The notice describes it as telling the court what a member dislikes about the settlement while remaining eligible for payment, with a catch that matters here: Subclass A members stay eligible, but Subclass B members must still submit a claim to be paid. An objection is therefore not a substitute for a claim form in Subclass B, and the same December 1 date that lets a Subclass A member object without losing the payment gives a Subclass B member no such cushion.

Subclass B’s route is the only one with a proof standard attached. The notice says claims must show it is more likely than not that the member belongs to Subclass B and is entitled to a payment, and that forms go online at ReturnSettlement.com or by mail, submitted or postmarked no later than December 1, 2026. The notice text reviewed names that standard but no specific document list, which leaves the practical question of how much support a Subclass B claim needs to the administrator and the court.

Two subclass definitions decide whether a December 1 form is needed at all

The settlement agreement defines Subclass A in one sentence: all persons whose transactions are included in Settlement Subclass A. Subclass B is all persons who had transactions at issue in the Settlement Class other than those in Subclass A. Neither quoted definition names a purchase date, an item type or a refund status, so which side a given return falls on turns on the transaction lists behind the definitions and not on anything a shopper can read off the definitions themselves.

That matters because the class itself is broad. The agreement covers anyone who initiated a return or requested a refund on a physical product bought through Amazon.com and, per Amazon’s records, received in the United States since September 5, 2017, and who either never received a refund, received an untimely or incorrect one, or was refunded and later charged again. A class member may therefore sit in Subclass A, where no form is needed, or in Subclass B, where a form submitted by December 1 is the only route to a payment, and the notice states that Subclass B members must file in order to be paid.

The official route runs through the court-appointed administrator and needs no intermediary. ReturnSettlement.com accepts Subclass B claims online or provides a form for mailing to Amazon Return Policy Litigation, Attn: Claim Request, PO Box 10, East Brunswick, NJ 08816-9998, and the notice lists a phone line at 1-888-553-4246 and an email address, info@ReturnSettlement.com. What remains is the unglamorous work of confirming which subclass applies, calendaring December 1 and March 16, and tracking any payment through final approval.


A paid service for tracking open class-action settlements

The Amazon return case sorts members into a subclass that is paid automatically and one that must file by December 1, so a list of open settlements is only the start of the work. MoneyPilot is a paid subscription service that lists open class-action settlements, shows which ones may match a member, files claim forms for members and tracks deadlines and payout status.

See which open settlements MoneyPilot lists →

This article was produced with AI assistance and reviewed by The Money Overview’s editors.

Avatar photo

Daniel Harper

Daniel is a finance writer covering personal finance topics including budgeting, credit, and beginner investing. He began his career contributing to his Substack, where he covered consumer finance trends and practical money topics for everyday readers. Since then, he has written for a range of personal finance blogs and fintech platforms, focusing on clear, straightforward content that helps readers make more informed financial decisions.​