On October 2, 2026, a gallon of regular gasoline cost an average of $6.40 in California and $3.79 in Indiana, the cheapest state in the country. That $2.61 gap means a 12-gallon fill-up runs about $31 more on the West Coast than in the Midwest. For retirees who drive a few thousand miles a year and live on benefits that adjust only once annually, the spread matters less as a headline than as a measure of how much of a fixed budget a car quietly claims depending on the ZIP code.
What AAA’s state table shows for California and Indiana
AAA’s state-by-state table, marked “Price as of 10/2/26,” lists California at $6.4008 a gallon for regular, the highest of any state, and Indiana at $3.7902, the lowest. The table covers every state and the District of Columbia, so the superlatives are not a sampling artifact: no other entry sits above California or below Indiana. Rounded to the cent, the two figures are $6.40 and $3.79.
The runners-up on each end are well separated. Hawaii, the second-most expensive entry among the states, is at $5.6316, followed by Washington at $5.4891 and Nevada at $5.4882. At the other end, Georgia is at $3.9131 and Texas at $3.9397, with Mississippi at $3.9596 and Tennessee at $3.9584 close behind. Indiana therefore leads the cheap group by about 12 cents over Georgia, while California sits roughly 77 cents above Hawaii.
The state figures are a day fresher than the national numbers AAA publishes on its home page. The table on October 2 implies a national average of $4.3961, while the home page, last updated October 1, put the national average at $4.4137, against $4.0954 a month earlier and $3.1605 a year earlier. On those figures, a gallon cost about 8 percent more than a month before and roughly 40 percent more than twelve months before. AAA is the sole source for every state and national figure in this paragraph and the two above.
Why a gap this wide persists between states
Federal weekly data points the same direction, though with different numbers because it comes from a different survey and a different week. The Energy Information Administration’s weekly pump survey for the week ending September 28 put California at $6.189, the West Coast region at $5.724 and the Gulf Coast at $3.924, with a U.S. regular average of $4.465. The EIA release came out on September 29, so its California figure is not directly comparable to AAA’s October 2 reading, but both place California far above the Gulf Coast refining belt.
The regional split is wide in the federal data: the West Coast region averages $1.80 a gallon more than the Gulf Coast, and California alone is $2.27 above it. Within AAA’s table, the cheapest dozen or so entries are largely Southern and Midwestern states such as Georgia, Texas, Mississippi, Tennessee, Louisiana and South Carolina, alongside Indiana. The most expensive group is Western: California, Hawaii, Washington, Nevada, Alaska and Oregon.
The AAA and EIA readings do not agree to the cent, and neither claims to. AAA’s California average of $6.4008 is about 21 cents above EIA’s $6.189 a few days earlier, a difference that reflects the several days between the two readings and the two organizations’ separate surveys. Neither series supports a story that prices are falling in the state: the EIA figure and the AAA figure are both far above any state east of the Rockies.
Delaware offers a reminder of how a state can look cheap without being cheapest. AAA lists Delaware at $4.3089 on October 2, a level that sits below the national average of $4.3961 but still $0.52 above Indiana. A state labeled the cheapest in a regional or partial list can therefore fall to the middle of the full table once all states are counted, which is why only the complete AAA table can name Indiana as the low.
What the spread costs older drivers on fixed incomes
The Bureau of Labor Statistics says the gasoline index rose 3.9 percent in August and 27.4 percent over the 12 months ended that month, in the consumer price release published September 11, 2026. That is the national backdrop. A retiree whose income is a Social Security check, a pension or an annuity that does not change monthly absorbs those increases out of the same dollars, and the state-level spread decides how big the bite is.
The arithmetic is simple and sets an upper bound on what a state line can cost. At the October 2 averages, one gallon in California costs $2.6106 more than in Indiana. A retiree who burns 200 gallons a year, which is about 5,000 miles at 25 miles per gallon, would pay roughly $522 more a year in California than in Indiana at these prices. That figure is the product of the AAA numbers and an assumed driving pattern, not a number published by any agency.
Low-mileage drivers are in a different position from commuters. A person who drives to a pharmacy, a clinic and a grocery store a few times a week buys gas in small amounts, so the fuel line is a modest share of the budget even at $6.40. The pinch for older residents of high-price states is less the fill-up than the price of everything delivered by truck, and the fact that benefits do not reprice until the next annual adjustment.
Within a state the pump price is not uniform either. AAA’s table reports state averages, so a county or a stretch of highway can run well above or below the figure, and Indiana’s $3.7902 is a statewide mean rather than a price available at every station. The state averages are a day-stamped snapshot, and with the national average moving by almost two cents between October 1 and October 2, the extremes may shift before this page is read.
What the record does support is narrow and sourced. AAA’s October 2 table names California the highest at $6.4008 and Indiana the lowest at $3.7902; the national average that day was $4.3961; and the EIA and the BLS agree that Western prices run far above the Gulf Coast and that gasoline is sharply costlier than a year ago. Whether the gap narrows will show in AAA’s next daily table and in the EIA’s next weekly survey.
Bills with a relief program behind them
Fuel is one of several household costs that arrive whether or not income moves, and some of the others, such as property taxes and heating and cooling bills, have relief programs attached that rarely apply on their own. Older homeowners and renters in many states can qualify for them, but each has its own filing window.
The Senior Property Tax & Home-Cost Relief Kit sets the circuit-breaker credit that includes renters beside heating, cooling and home-repair help, so a household can see which of the two its own situation points to.
Find out which home-cost relief programs the kit covers →
This article was researched and drafted with the assistance of AI and reviewed by The Money Overview editorial team.