About 15,000 people in the Tulsa area with Aetna Medicare Advantage or employer coverage have been out of network at Hillcrest HealthCare System since Nov. 1, when the two sides’ agreement expired without a replacement. As of Nov. 7, no new contract has been announced. Hillcrest and Aetna each say they remain willing to keep talking.
The out-of-network status covers Hillcrest, its facilities and its employed providers, and it applies to Aetna’s Medicare Advantage plans along with its employer-sponsored commercial plans. Aetna Better Health, the company’s Medicaid plan, is not affected. That makes the split inside Aetna’s Oklahoma membership important: retirees on a Medicare Advantage plan are in the group that lost Hillcrest.
What Hillcrest and Aetna are each saying
Hillcrest’s own notice, updated Nov. 1, says the Aetna agreement was set to expire that day and no new deal was reached. “Hillcrest is now out of network with all Aetna insurance plans,” the page states. Hillcrest argues that Aetna reimburses it at rates well below market averages and points to payment delays and denied claims for care already provided.
Aetna tells it differently. In a statement to News On 6, the insurer said “Hillcrest HealthCare System chose to terminate the Aetna agreement,” that it offered fair rate terms and that “we remain far apart on terms because Hillcrest HealthCare System is asking for price increases.” Aetna added that it remains willing to negotiate to keep Hillcrest in its networks. No spokesperson is named on either side.
Hillcrest says Aetna leadership has not engaged with its leaders despite six months of attempts. Becker’s Payer reported that both parties told the publication they remain open to negotiating. Becker’s, which published Nov. 2, attributes the figure of about 15,000 affected people to Hillcrest and counts both employer-sponsored and Medicare Advantage members.
Where an Aetna Medicare Advantage member stands
Anyone on an Aetna Medicare Advantage plan in northeast Oklahoma who sees a Hillcrest doctor, uses a Hillcrest hospital or has surgery scheduled there now faces out-of-network rules. The choice is between waiting for a contract, arranging care elsewhere in Aetna’s network, or choosing a different 2027 plan during Annual Enrollment, which runs Oct. 15 through Dec. 7.
Stay ahead of Medicare plan news: Miss an enrollment or claim deadline and the money can be gone. Join the Retirement Money Brief and we’ll send you our 2027 Medicare Plan-Change Checklist as a welcome gift.
Get the Brief + the plan-change checklist →
We may earn a commission from links on this page.
Emergency care is the one part Hillcrest has said is settled. Its page says emergency services at Hillcrest remain covered at in-network rates, and it prints “Emergency care is always covered” as a heading. The same page says some patients may qualify for continuity-of-care protections and tells patients to call Aetna at the number on the back of the insurance card.
Continuity of care is the lever most worth asking about. Plans commonly allow a patient in the middle of treatment to keep seeing a provider at in-network cost for a limited time. Hillcrest and News On 6, which reported on Nov. 2, both say some patients may qualify and send questions to Aetna, so the call to the plan is how a patient learns whether a specific course of treatment is covered.
What a 2027 plan has to answer
Hillcrest’s notice points Medicare-eligible patients to Annual Enrollment, which opened Oct. 15, to consider plans that include Hillcrest in network. That is the cleaner exit for a retiree who wants to stay with Hillcrest doctors. A plan chosen on Medicare’s Plan Finder by Dec. 7 starts Jan. 1.
Network listings change during the year, so a doctor’s name on a plan’s list is worth confirming with the Hillcrest clinic itself before enrolling. Hillcrest’s insurance page lists the plans it accepts, and its staff can say whether a plan in question is contracted. The plan’s own provider directory should agree with what the clinic says.
Drugs belong in the same check. A retiree who switches plans to keep a Hillcrest cardiologist can land in a plan with a different formulary, a different pharmacy network and a different monthly cost. The 2027 plan has to cover the doctor, the hospital and the prescriptions together, or the savings from keeping one can be lost on the others.
The other path is to stay in the Aetna plan and use Aetna’s in-network doctors and hospitals while the dispute plays out. If an agreement is signed, Hillcrest would return to the network, though neither side has said when. Because Aetna calls the two sides “far apart” on price, waiting through the Dec. 7 deadline is a bet on a negotiation with no announced end.
If the dispute drags into 2027
Members of Aetna Medicare Advantage plans who miss Dec. 7 get one more chance. From Jan. 1 through March 31, the Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period lets someone already in a Medicare Advantage plan switch to a different plan once or move to Original Medicare. That window can fix a mistake but cannot undo three months of out-of-network bills.
Switching to Original Medicare removes the network but adds the supplement question. Medigap insurers in most states can ask health questions outside certain protected windows, so a retiree with an ongoing condition should know the underwriting rules before leaving a Medicare Advantage plan.
The employer-plan side of the 15,000 has its own clock. Workers and retirees on Aetna coverage through an employer generally have to wait for the plan’s open enrollment or a qualifying event, so those members are likelier to depend on the Hillcrest negotiation than on a plan switch. Anyone in that group should ask the benefits office what dates apply.
Using Hillcrest doctors on an Aetna plan?
A Hillcrest patient on an Aetna Medicare Advantage plan has until Dec. 7 to choose a 2027 plan that lists Hillcrest, and Aetna says the two sides are far apart. A wrong guess means out-of-network bills for a specialist or a hospital stay that a different plan would have covered.
The 2027 Medicare Open Enrollment Decision Kit includes a cost calculator spreadsheet that compares plans on cost, drugs and doctors, and a provider call script for confirming with a Hillcrest clinic what it accepts. The calculator is an Excel workbook that runs the comparison for a keep, switch or wait decision.
The kit also lays out the Medigap and IRMAA checkpoints and a 51-state Medicare help directory, so a retiree weighing a move out of Aetna has the supplement rules and a counselor’s number in the same file.
Get the plan calculator and Hillcrest call script in the Decision Kit →
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.