Skip to main content

The Money Overview

Fannie Mae now requires an appraiser using the UAD 3.6 form to find a home’s highest and best use is residential, effective immediately

Fannie Mae now requires an appraiser using the UAD 3.6 form to conclude that a property’s highest and best use, as improved or as proposed, is a residential use, and the requirement took effect immediately instead of on a later calendar date. The change sits in Selling Guide announcement SEL-2026-08, issued on September 2, 2026 and reissued on September 23. It swaps a test built around the property’s present use for one that asks what the property is, or is proposed to be, once its improvements are counted. For a conventional loan on a one- to four-unit home, the appraisal behind the loan now answers a differently worded question.

Highest and best use is a standard step in valuation. Before an appraiser compares a property with recent sales, the appraiser decides which use the value should be measured as, and that conclusion steers which comparable sales are relevant. Fannie Mae’s change does not alter that sequence. It sets the answer an appraisal must reach for a loan the company will buy: residential, whether the home stands today as improved or is being built or altered as proposed.

The SEL-2026-08 wording that replaces present use with residential use as improved or as proposed

The operative sentence in Fannie Mae’s Selling Guide announcement SEL-2026-08 directs lenders to “require the property’s highest and best use, as improved or as proposed, to be a residential use, rather than requiring it to be the property’s present use.” The phrase “as proposed” matters for a purchase of a home that is under construction or about to be renovated, because the appraisal can rest on plans while the building still differs from what the appraiser concludes it will be. The announcement does not give an example of either case.

The announcement also reworks what counts as residential. Fannie Mae describes the property as a primarily residential one- to four-unit property, with any non-residential use subordinate to the residential use, and says that wording replaces the previous “residential in nature” guidance. A building with a small commercial space attached would be read against that subordinate-use language, so the residential side has to be the dominant one. The announcement states no percentage or square-footage line between dominant and subordinate.

Fannie Mae’s own summary of the announcement frames the change as support for the new reporting form, describing it as “clarifying highest and best use requirements for Uniform Appraisal Dataset (UAD) 3.6 appraisal assignments to support the new Uniform Residential Appraisal Report (URAR) reporting requirements.” The word clarifying is Fannie Mae’s. The summary does not describe the change as a tightening or a loosening of lending standards, and it attaches no loan-to-value ratio, credit score or price figure to it.

Why legacy-form appraisals and loans outside Fannie Mae sit outside the new test

The new language is confined to one form. The announcement says the update applies only to UAD 3.6 appraisal assignments and does not apply to appraisal reports completed using legacy appraisal report forms. An appraisal finished on an older form is therefore not measured against the as-improved-or-as-proposed wording in this announcement, and the announcement does not say how many appraisals are being completed on each form or when the legacy forms stop being used.

The requirement also follows Fannie Mae’s reach. As a buyer of conventional loans, Fannie Mae writes the Selling Guide for lenders that sell loans to it, so the rule binds those conventional loans and not FHA or VA loans, which follow the rules of their own agencies. A loan a lender keeps on its own books is likewise outside the Selling Guide, which means two buyers financing similar houses through different channels could receive appraisals judged on different yardsticks.

Fannie Mae’s Uniform Appraisal Dataset page describes UAD 3.6 as an updated appraisal dataset aligned with the MISMO v3.6 industry data standard, and presents the URAR as a single report that replaces earlier government-sponsored-enterprise forms with a more flexible, dynamic structure for reporting across residential property types. The page also lists a playbook and frequently asked questions devoted to highest and best use. The announcement itself does not reproduce their content.

How the immediate date differs from the December 1 date on the rental-income changes in the same announcement

SEL-2026-08 carries three sets of changes on more than one clock. The rental-income restructuring, which includes the standardized treatment of investment properties bought within 45 days of the subject property, becomes mandatory for loans with application dates on and after December 1, 2026. A reissue note in the announcement says it was reissued “to revise the required implementation date for rental income policy changes from Nov. 1, 2026 to Dec. 1, 2026.” The highest-and-best-use item is not among the policies that note names, and the third set, on Native American Conventional Lending Initiative eligibility, is separate again.

The highest-and-best-use item runs on a different trigger. The announcement says the change “is effective immediately for appraisal reports completed using UAD 3.6,” which ties it to the appraisal report rather than to the date a borrower applied for the loan. By that wording, a borrower whose application is dated before December 1 can still receive an appraisal governed by the residential-use test if the report was completed on UAD 3.6, while the rental-income rules for the same loan stay optional for lenders until December 1.

The announcement names no cutoff for reports completed before it was issued on September 2, and the reissued version still states that the highest-and-best-use change is effective immediately. Anyone reading a November 1 date into this item is therefore reading the wrong item: that date belonged only to the rental-income changes, and it has itself been replaced by December 1.

What Fannie Mae has put on the record is narrow and specific: a residential-use conclusion, the UAD 3.6 form and an immediate date. What the announcement does not say is how an appraiser who reaches a different conclusion is to report it, or what a lender does with a loan whose appraisal lands on a non-residential use. Those answers sit in the Selling Guide and the UAD 3.6 Policy Supplement to which the announcement points lenders.


Home costs that sit outside the appraisal

Homeowners and renters carry property-tax, utility and repair bills that no appraisal measures, and relief exists for several of them. Each program has its own application and its own renewal date.

The Senior Property Tax & Home-Cost Relief Kit includes the 5 kinds of property-tax relief, heating, cooling and home-repair help, and an application log and renewal calendar.

Open The Senior Property Tax & Home-Cost Relief Kit to sort the carrying costs an SEL-2026-08 appraisal never covers →

This article was researched and drafted with the assistance of AI and reviewed by The Money Overview editorial team.


More in Buying & Selling