Illinois state retirees in Aetna’s TRAIL Medicare Advantage plan will keep BJC HealthCare in network for 2027 under a one-year agreement, even though BJC leaves Aetna’s and Anthem’s other Medicare Advantage plans on Jan. 1. Illinois’ Central Management Services estimates about 5,000 plan members are affected. The deal covers the state’s group plan only, not individual Aetna policies.
TRAIL, short for Total Retiree Advantage Illinois, is the Aetna Medicare Advantage prescription drug plan the state offers to retirees, annuitants and survivors of the State Employees’ Group Insurance Program, the Teachers’ Retirement Insurance Program (TRIP) and the College Insurance Program (CIP). Illinois CMS says it cannot break out how many University of Illinois System retirees and dependents are in the 5,000.
The split matters most to people living in the St. Louis metro, where two groups of Aetna members now face different Januarys. Retirees in TRAIL keep Barnes-Jewish and other BJC doctors through Dec. 31, 2027. Anyone on an individual Aetna or Anthem Medicare Advantage plan loses BJC on Jan. 1 unless they move by Dec. 7, so the first step is to find the plan name on the card.
Stay ahead of Medicare plan news: Miss an enrollment or claim deadline and the money can be gone. Join the Retirement Money Brief and we’ll send you our 2027 Medicare Plan-Change Checklist as a welcome gift.
Get the Brief + the plan-change checklist →
We may earn a commission from links on this page.
What the one-year agreement covers
BJC’s Medicare page says BJC and Aetna reached a deal that keeps in-network equivalent services for TRAIL members in Aetna’s Medicare Advantage PPO coverage through 2027. BJC calls it a “one-year transition plan” that gives the State of Illinois time to consider plan options for 2028 and beyond.
The page is explicit that the extension applies to group TRAIL plans only. Individual Aetna Medicare Advantage members, and all Anthem Medicare Advantage members, go out of network with BJC on Jan. 1, 2027. BJC says the exit follows years of trying to resolve administrative burden and payment issues with both insurers.
The agreement came after weeks of pressure from Springfield. On Oct. 23, five state senators and nine state representatives signed a letter to BJC, Aetna and Illinois CMS, and Capitol News Illinois reported that they asked for a briefing if there was no deal by Nov. 6.
State Sen. Chapin Rose, a Mahomet Republican, told the News-Gazette that patients who go to Barnes-Jewish are usually seeking specialty care. “You have people who are scared, rightly scared,” Rose said. He plans to file legislation on retiree plan choice in the spring.
Before the deal, retirees were making plans around BJC
Capitol News Illinois found retirees changing treatment schedules ahead of the exit. Tim Rice, 65, of Alto Pass, was making six trips to St. Louis to finish cancer treatment before Thanksgiving. Rosemary Rouse, of Tunnel Hill, had an appointment canceled by Washington University unless she changed insurers.
Illinois CMS had told participants in an Oct. 15 memo that BJC hospitals would keep serving patients whose care is “medically necessary,” without defining the term. Aetna spokesman Phil Blando said BJC and WashU physicians were willing to see members for continuity of care and in limited situations.
The state, not a university, runs the plan. Steve Witmer, assistant director of media relations for the University of Illinois System, told the News-Gazette that the TRAIL Medicare Advantage plan is available only through Aetna and is administered by Illinois CMS, not the university system. CMS spokeswoman Cynthia Johnson said the agency and the governor’s office were “actively engaged” with Aetna and BJC before the deal.
The TRAIL group is a small share of the market. Federal figures cited by Capitol News Illinois put more than 72,000 people in the 15-county St. Louis area in Aetna Medicare Advantage plans as of October 2026, which leaves most of those members outside the one-year deal.
BJC is one of many systems stepping back from Medicare Advantage. Becker’s Hospital Review counted 38 health systems nationwide that have ended contracts with various Medicare Advantage plans, about 10 of them involving Aetna, the News-Gazette reported Nov. 6.
Eligibility for TRAIL requires living in the United States or a U.S. territory and being enrolled in Medicare Parts A and B because of age or disability. Covered dependents can be included, so the count of affected people can run past the number of retirees themselves.
TRAIL enrollment dates and where to call
The state’s TRAIL page lists open enrollment as Oct. 15 to Nov. 16, 2026, and says no elections are accepted before or after those dates. The News-Gazette reported Nov. 6 that Illinois CMS extended the window to Nov. 23 from Nov. 15.
Both dates fall well before Medicare’s Dec. 7 deadline for individual plans, so TRAIL members who want to change have less time than other Medicare Advantage members. Changes go through the MyBenefits Service Center at 844-251-1777 on weekdays from 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. or at MyBenefits.Illinois.gov, where the correct closing date can be confirmed.
Illinois CMS added four TRAIL seminars in the Metro East, on Nov. 4 in Edwardsville and Nov. 12 in East Alton. The seminar on Nov. 12 is still ahead and gives retirees a chance to ask the state’s own staff how the BJC deal fits their situation.
Plans BJC still takes, and what 2028 holds
For retirees who decide to leave TRAIL, BJC lists Medicare Advantage plans from Devoted Health, Essence, Humana and UnitedHealthcare as in network for 2027. It also takes Original Medicare and most Medicare Supplement, or Medigap, plans.
Leaving a state retiree plan is a larger step than swapping one private plan for another, and the MyBenefits line is the place to ask what changes. BJC’s designated Medicare advisor, Chapter Advisory, gives no-cost guidance at 314-936-6108, and Medicare’s own line is 1-800-633-4227.
The one-year term puts the decision in Springfield’s hands for 2028. BJC says the arrangement gives the state time to consider options, and Rose’s planned bill on retiree plan choice signals that lawmakers expect the question to return. A retiree who stays in TRAIL for 2027 is covered at BJC for that year only.
For St. Louis-area retirees, the useful test is simple. A member on the state’s group TRAIL plan has BJC through 2027. A member on any other Aetna or Anthem Medicare Advantage plan does not, and the November and December dates are the last chance to change that.
Staying in TRAIL, or moving before the window closes?
The state’s enrollment window closes Nov. 16, or Nov. 23 on the News-Gazette’s account, while individual plans run to Dec. 7. The state’s page says no elections are accepted after its closing date, and the BJC agreement covers 2027 only.
The 2027 Medicare Open Enrollment Decision Kit gives a retiree a way to weigh TRAIL against the alternatives in writing. It includes a cost calculator spreadsheet that compares plans on cost, drugs and doctors, and a prescription-by-plan comparison for the drugs the retiree takes.
Part 6 of the kit holds phone scripts and a call log for the calls to MyBenefits, a plan and a doctor’s office, so each answer about BJC and the 2027 network is written down with a date.
Get the TRAIL-versus-alternatives calculator and call log before the enrollment date →
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.