Families caring for aging parents at home can, in many states, receive Medicaid payments for that work through self-directed personal assistance programs. The federal legal framework gives states wide latitude to decide whether spouses, parents, or adult children qualify as paid caregivers, and that latitude created a patchwork of rules that shifted sharply during and after the COVID-19 public health emergency. Virginia’s Department of Medical Assistance Services, for example, updated its rules on legally responsible individuals effective November 11, 2023, tightening eligibility after temporary pandemic-era flexibilities expired. The question now is whether states that kept broader payment rules will see different patterns in institutional care spending than those that pulled back.
Post-pandemic rule changes put family caregiver pay at stake
During the public health emergency, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services approved waivers that let states temporarily expand who could be paid to deliver personal care. Some states used those emergency waivers to allow legally responsible individuals, including parents and spouses, to receive Medicaid reimbursement for caregiving tasks that would otherwise go unpaid or require a hired aide. The rationale was straightforward: home health worker shortages left thousands of Medicaid beneficiaries without adequate support, and family members were already doing the work.
When the federal emergency declarations ended, each state had to decide whether to keep those broader rules or revert to pre-pandemic restrictions. Virginia chose to tighten. Its DMAS bulletin on legally responsible individuals effective November 11, 2023, aligned state policy with the conclusion of certain federal flexibilities granted during the emergency. That single bulletin illustrates a larger, state-by-state divergence: some programs still pay family members under self-directed service models, while others have restored older limits that exclude them.
These reversals matter financially and emotionally for families. A parent who left a job to provide round-the-clock care may suddenly lose income when a state tightens eligibility, even though the care needs have not changed. In states that preserved expanded options, relatives can remain part of the paid workforce, potentially delaying nursing home placement and giving older adults more control over where they live.
Federal authorities that let states pay family caregivers
The legal architecture behind these programs sits in Title XIX of the Social Security Act. Section 1915(j) establishes that a state Medicaid plan may provide self-directed personal assistance services in which participants exercise choice and control over budgets, planning, purchasing, and the selection of providers. In practice, that means a Medicaid beneficiary can act as the employer of record, recruiting, hiring, training, and supervising their own workers, including relatives willing to serve as aides, if state rules allow it.
States access these arrangements through several federal authorities. CMS lists self-directed options operating under Section 1915(i), 1915(j), 1915(k), and 1915(c) waivers or state plan amendments. Each pathway carries different requirements around enrollment caps, service definitions, and provider qualifications. The result is that a daughter caring for her mother in one state may qualify for hourly Medicaid pay, while a daughter in an adjacent state doing identical work receives nothing.
States also decide how to define “legally responsible individuals,” a category that typically includes spouses and, for minors, parents. Some programs allow these relatives to be hired only when no other worker is available; others bar them entirely or restrict them to specific tasks. The pandemic-era waivers temporarily loosened many of these limits, but as those waivers expired, longstanding debates about fraud risk, quality oversight, and budget pressures resurfaced.
How families can navigate the patchwork
For families weighing their options, the first step is to contact the state Medicaid agency and ask specifically about self-directed services or consumer direction. Program names vary, but intake staff should be able to explain whether beneficiaries can hire relatives, which relatives qualify, and what training or background checks are required. In some cases, an independent fiscal intermediary handles payroll and taxes, reducing administrative burden on the family.
It is also important to clarify how many hours of care Medicaid will authorize and whether those hours can be split among multiple caregivers. A state may, for example, approve a weekly block of personal care that can be divided between an adult child and a non-relative aide. Families should ask whether the plan pays different rates for agency staff and consumer-directed workers, and whether live-in caregivers are treated differently from those who come and go.
Advocates recommend documenting the time and tasks already being provided before applying. A detailed log of bathing, mobility assistance, meal preparation, and supervision can help assessors understand the true level of need. If a state has recently tightened rules around legally responsible individuals, families may want to explore whether other relatives, such as siblings or adult grandchildren, can be enrolled as paid workers instead.
Ultimately, the evolution of these policies will shape how and where older adults receive care. States that maintain robust self-directed models with room for family caregivers may see more people able to remain safely at home, though they must still guard against misuse and ensure adequate oversight. States that restrict payment to traditional agencies could face renewed workforce shortages and higher institutional costs if families cannot sustain unpaid care. For now, families must navigate a landscape defined as much by state policy choices as by the federal authorities that made those choices possible.
Free for readers: The free Retirement Shield newsletter sends plain-English help keeping more of your money in retirement — the scams to dodge, the benefits you’re owed, and what’s changing with Social Security and Medicare, a couple times a week. Get the free newsletter.
