Skip to main content

The Money Overview

About half of U.S. mortgages still carry rates of 4% or lower, keeping owners locked in, Fed Governor Barr says

“About half of all mortgages still carry rates of 4 percent or lower,” Federal Reserve Governor Michael Barr said on Sept. 23, and nearly 80% of outstanding loans have a rate below 6%. Fed staff calculations put those shares as of the second quarter of 2026. Against a new-purchase rate above 7%, Barr argued, owners with cheap legacy loans have little reason to sell, which thins the supply of homes for everyone else.

The 4% legacy loans in the Fed’s National Mortgage Database

Barr’s speech drew the mortgage distribution from Federal Reserve Board staff calculations using the National Mortgage Database, with figures for the second quarter of 2026. Roughly half of outstanding mortgages carry a rate of 4% or lower, and nearly 80% are below 6%. Those shares describe existing loans, not new originations, which is why they can look so different from the rate quoted to a buyer this week.

The new-loan rate is far higher. Freddie Mac’s Primary Mortgage Market Survey for Sept. 24, 2026 reported an average 30-year fixed rate of 7.03%, up from 6.95% a week earlier and 6.30% a year earlier. The 15-year rate stood at 6.42%, compared with 5.49% a year before. A household with a 4% loan that moves to a 7.03% loan pays a much larger share of each monthly payment as interest on the same balance.

Barr called this the lock-in effect. In his description, it reduces both housing supply and housing demand, because current owners hold back listings and would-be buyers face costs that a seller in the same position would not. In tight markets, he said, the effect can raise prices. He cited a 2024 Federal Reserve staff paper by Aladangady, Krimmel and Scharlemann titled “Locked In: Mobility, Market Tightness, and House Prices.”

Why fewer sales matter for buyers who cannot wait

The lock-in point sits inside a longer argument about scarcity. Barr estimated the national shortage at 2 million to 5.5 million housing units and listed zoning, construction productivity, the 2007 to 2012 collapse in homebuilding and post-pandemic cost inflation as causes. Lock-in adds a demand-side friction on top of those: even where homes exist, the owners of the existing stock are less likely to trade them.

Census data show how tight the owner market is. The Bureau’s Housing Vacancies and Homeownership report for the second quarter of 2026 put the homeowner vacancy rate at 1.2%, not statistically different from 1.1% a year earlier, and the homeownership rate at 65.0%, virtually unchanged from a year before. A vacancy rate near 1% leaves few homes for sale at any moment, so each owner who stays put matters more.

Barr also connected the affordability problem to the Atlanta Fed’s Home Ownership Affordability Monitor, which fell to 68 in July 2026, the lowest in 21 years. The monitor bakes the current mortgage rate into its cost formula, so a rate above 7% weighs on the score directly. A reading below 100 means a median-income family cannot afford a median-priced home at current rates, and the lock-in effect helps keep median prices elevated.

Barr said ownership costs extend beyond the loan rate. Property taxes rise with home prices, he noted, and homeowners insurance has risen significantly in recent years, in part because of higher rebuilding costs, citing a February 2026 National Bureau of Economic Research working paper by Joshua Blonz and co-authors. An owner with a 4% loan is insulated from the rate shock, but not from a reassessment or a higher insurance renewal, and the same cost pressures add to what a buyer would face on a replacement home.

The speech gave first-time buyers a specific number. Barr cited the Federal Reserve’s 2024 household well-being survey, in which 68% of prospective first-time buyers said they could not afford a down payment. For them, the rate on an existing loan held by a seller is not the immediate obstacle. The obstacle is a price set by a market where few sellers list, and a rate that adds to the monthly bill even if the price were lower.

What Barr said the Fed can and cannot change

The monetary policy portion of the speech was brief. Barr said the Federal Open Market Committee increased the policy rate the previous week, a move he supported, and described it as an adjustment in the right direction after the Fed had been out of position. He said mortgage rates are generally lower when inflation is lower, and that the Fed is working toward that goal. He offered no forecast for rates or for lock-in.

The reference rate is the second piece. The Atlanta Fed’s monitor updates monthly, so its August and September readings will show whether the 68 was a trough or a step lower. If rates stay above 7%, the share of loans under 4% will fall only as those borrowers sell, refinance or pay off, a process that takes years because the loans are a large slice of the total.

That points to a gradual thaw rather than a release. Barr’s other recommendations, from zoning reform to housing tax credits, aim at adding homes so that the share of buyers and sellers stuck in place matters less. He also said additional policy adjustments are likely to be needed, without saying which. The speech leaves unanswered how many owners with sub-4% loans will hold on for a full decade, and how many homes that keeps off the market.


Locked-in owners still carry property-tax and repair bills

Owners who stay in homes financed at 4% or less avoid a higher mortgage payment, but the other recurring costs of the house continue and often rise. The Senior Property Tax & Home-Cost Relief Kit is for older homeowners and renters sorting out property-tax relief and help with heating, cooling and repairs, and the gap it addresses is the paperwork between those programs.

The Senior Property Tax & Home-Cost Relief Kit is an 11-page kit that explains the 5 kinds of property-tax relief and the heating, cooling and home-repair help that owners can apply for.

Compare the relief types against the renewal calendar in The Senior Property Tax & Home-Cost Relief Kit.

This article was researched and drafted with the assistance of AI and reviewed by The Money Overview editorial team.


More in Mortgages & Rates