Social Security’s own inspector general has found that 54 of 175 sampled cases selected for tax refund offsets were not handled in line with agency policy, a 31 percent failure rate across overpayments that trace back to benefits once paid on a child’s record. The SSA Office of the Inspector General (OIG) posted the audit, report 052502, on September 30, 2026, and the agency agreed to implement its five recommendations. Within the sample, $227,012 in overpayments was not resolved properly, and the largest group of failures involved benefit withholding that SSA never attempted, a missed step upstream of the refund offset itself.
Inside the kit: The Social Security Check Protection Kit pairs the 2026 payment calendar with the three SSA forms that stop or pause collection.
A 31 percent failure rate in the refund-offset sample
The audit set out to determine, in the OIG’s words, “whether the Social Security Administration (SSA) resolved overpayments in accordance with policy to individuals who received child benefits.” That scope matters: the report concerns debts attached to child benefit records, where the person now owing money is often a former beneficiary who is an adult years after the payments stopped. It does not cover every Social Security overpayment, and its findings should not be read as a verdict on how the agency handles all recovery.
Auditors drew 175 individuals who had been selected for the Treasury Offset Program, the federal channel for taking tax refunds to repay delinquent debts. Of those, 54 (31 percent) were not handled per policy, while 121 (69 percent) were. These are counts from a sample, not projections, and the dollar figure attached to the 54 cases, $227,012, is likewise the amount found in the sampled files rather than an estimate for the whole population.
The offset process has built-in stopping points that the OIG describes. After the agency’s collection system selects an overpaid person, it sends a notice of planned actions, and if there is no response within 60 days and all requirements are still met, the system refers the person to the Department of the Treasury. A notice returned undeliverable halts the referral until SSA obtains a valid address and sends it again. The audit’s concern was less the offset step than what SSA was supposed to do before and around it.
Withholding that never started and records that were never cleaned up
By the OIG’s count, 48 of the 54 cases were benefit-withholding failures, in which SSA did not attempt to recover $216,373 through withholding from benefits. In 25 of them, employees never began withholding from either the overpaid person or a contingently liable person living in the same household. Seven of those 25 files carried alerts dated between August 2024 and September 2025 that employees had not acted on, which suggests the signal existed but the follow-through did not.
Another 23 cases involved contingently liable individuals living in separate households, where employees did not monitor records to decide whether benefits should be withheld. The remaining six of the 54 were record failures: employees did not update benefit records to remove incorrect overpayments or fix the coding the offset system needs to make proper referrals. Together the three patterns describe a system in which debts stayed open, stayed on children’s records or moved toward Treasury collection without the intervening steps being taken.
Contingent liability is the mechanism that makes this consequential. Under the policy the OIG quotes, when an overpaid person is not due a benefit and collection from that person fails, SSA may recover from benefits payable to another person on the same record, including someone receiving child benefits. The arrangement is meant to be temporary, and employees should stop withholding when the overpaid person becomes re-entitled to benefits or begins receiving SSI. The root cause, according to the OIG, was that SSA lacked processes to alert employees about required actions on such cases.
The audit also examined a second group, 349 individuals whose child benefits SSA suspended or terminated but who remained contingently liable. In a sample of 10 from that group, all 10 were mishandled, with employees failing to remove overpayments totaling $1.9 million across the population. This group is a different sample and is not combined with the 54 of 175. Five recommendations followed, covering resolution of identified cases, review of roughly 6,600 people who no longer met contingent liability requirements, new employee notification controls, withholding alerts, and a review of improper record updates.
SSA agreed to implement the recommendations, according to the report. Agreement is not completion: the audit records no finished fix. Until the alerts and controls exist, the same gaps that produced the sample’s 54 cases remain the agency’s own documented description of how these debts are handled, and the OIG’s two samples differ sharply in how often those gaps appeared.
The 50 percent default rate and the 30-day pause run on SSA’s clock
For people holding an overpayment notice, the practical stakes are set by rates and windows SSA publishes separately from the audit. The agency’s resolve-overpayment page says it will automatically withhold 50% of a Title II benefit each month until the overpayment is repaid, or 10% of an SSI payment. The page was last updated in July 2025, and the agency’s main overpayments page does not publish a default percentage at all.
Timing is the second pressure. SSA’s overpayments page states that if a waiver request or appeal is submitted before 30 days have passed, collection will not begin until a decision is made. A separate form, SSA-634, is the request for a change in the overpayment recovery rate. A waiver or appeal pauses collection and a rate request changes how fast it proceeds, so the two answer different questions even though both arrive in response to the same notice.
The OIG’s closing warning explains why the distinction matters in these child-record cases: without improvements, individuals can incur financial burdens to repay overpayments that improperly remained on their benefit records. The free route is SSA itself, through its overpayments page and published forms, none of which require any paid product.
Choosing between a rate change and a pause on an old overpayment
The audit leaves a gap between what SSA’s own records may show and what a person holding a child-benefit overpayment notice must decide, because the notice sets a deadline and withholding rate without saying which form pauses collection and which only slows it. Sorting out SSA-634 against a waiver or appeal inside the 30-day window falls to the person responding.
The Social Security Check Protection Kit is an 18-page guide that includes the three SSA forms that stop or pause collection (SSA-561, SSA-632 and SSA-634) and an overpayment response worksheet for organizing that response.
Click here to get The Social Security Check Protection Kit →
This article was researched and drafted with the assistance of AI and reviewed by The Money Overview editorial team.