Direct Express, the prepaid debit card that carries federal benefits for people without a bank account, is changing banks. Fifth Third has replaced Comerica as the program’s financial agent, and existing cardholders will be moved to new Fifth Third cards in phases. Nobody has published a mailing date, so the cards will arrive without a published schedule.
Who is being moved to a Fifth Third card?
The Treasury Department’s Bureau of the Fiscal Service named Fifth Third the new financial agent in September 2025, under a five-year agreement that began September 9, according to a Fifth Third announcement. The program served approximately 3.4 million Americans at that point. Most of those cardholders have no bank account, and 57 percent have no income beyond government benefits.
Social Security spelled out the rollout to its own staff in an instruction dated May 19, 2026. New Direct Express enrollments have gone to Fifth Third since May 18. Existing customers move in what the agency calls a phased approach, with no immediate impact on them, and Social Security’s existing Direct Express processes stay the same until further notice.
For a cardholder waiting on a new card, the answer to the obvious worry is yes: the benefit keeps landing. The Direct Express cardholder site says federal benefits will be loaded automatically on each payment day, and that anyone with a Comerica card can keep using it until the new Fifth Third card arrives.
What changed this year: Social Security and Medicare change every year, and nobody sends you a memo. The Retirement Money Brief breaks down what changed and what to do. Bonus when you subscribe: our 2026 Social Security & SSI Payment Calendar.
Get the Brief and the payment calendar →
We may earn a commission from links on this page.
The 3.4 million figure is the headcount from that September 2025 announcement, not a count of cards already replaced. Neither the Treasury nor Fifth Third has said how many cardholders have a new card in hand. Fifth Third’s Bridgit Chayt, head of commercial payments, said the bank was proud to be selected and focused on secure, high-quality financial services.
What happens to someone who ends up with two cards?
The phased approach has one awkward side effect. Social Security’s instruction says benefits newly enrolled by a current Direct Express customer are being placed on a Fifth Third-branded card. A person who gets a second entitlement, for example, can end up holding a Comerica card and a Fifth Third card at once.
The agency tells its staff to explain that the person can consolidate by calling Treasury’s Electronic Payment Solution Center at 1-800-333-1795. Without consolidating, the cardholder keeps both cards and should not throw the Comerica card away. Benefits on the Comerica card will migrate to the Fifth Third card in the future, and problems with a replacement or a locked card still go to Comerica.
The Empire Justice Center, a New York legal advocacy group, wrote on July 31 that existing cardholders will transition later this year or in early 2027. The group says Comerica-issued cards remain valid until their expiration dates, and that Social Security has promised advance notice of the switch. Social Security’s own instruction says customers cannot be moved sooner than their turn comes.
How do the new card and app work?
The new card has to be activated. The cardholder site says that can be done through the new app, the website or the phone number on the back of the card, and that setup finishes when the cardholder chooses a 4-digit PIN. The new app is for newly issued Fifth Third cards only.
Cardholders who still hold a Comerica card should keep using their current app until further notice. The site says disputes, lost cards and stolen cards go to the toll-free number on the back of the card, and that a lost or stolen card is deactivated and replaced. Fees for both Fifth Third and Comerica cards are listed on the Direct Express website.
Treasury’s Direct Express page, last updated September 1, 2026, does not describe the changeover or give a date. It repeats a rule that matters to anyone considering leaving the card: federal benefit payments must be received electronically. Social Security staff are told that a customer who wants out can ask for direct deposit to a bank account instead. Keeping the card means the change comes with it.
What should cardholders watch for while the cards roll out?
A mass card replacement is the setting for impostor calls. The cardholder site says Direct Express, Fifth Third, Comerica and Mastercard will not ask for a card number, password, PIN or security code. It warns against emails or texts that ask a cardholder to verify or re-submit information through a link, and says to contact Direct Express directly instead.
Mail is the other weak point. Social Security’s instruction says a customer should confirm the email and mailing address on file with Comerica, and that Social Security does not automatically pass address or phone changes to the financial agent. A new card sent to an old address is a card no one has activated.
The open question is timing. Treasury, Fifth Third and Social Security have said the transition is phased and that notice comes first. None has said which cardholders go first or when the mailings begin, so the notice itself is the signal that a replacement card is on its way.
New Direct Express card not here yet?
A benefit that goes to a card nobody can use is the cost of getting the changeover wrong, and a card sent to an old address is the likeliest way it happens. The first day of a missing deposit is when the choices narrow.
The Social Security Check Protection Kit includes a first-24-hours plan for a late or missing payment, along with the 2026 payment calendar. It is built for the moment a deposit does not show up on its usual date.
The plan covers the first 24 hours after a deposit goes missing, and the calendar lists the 2026 payment dates.
More Financial Reading
- 21 Ways to Stretch a $2,087 Social Security Check
- 15 Places to Find Your Share of the $4.25 Billion States Give Back
- 15 Ways Retirees Are Tapping a Record $14.9 Trillion in Home Equity
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.