The Federal Trade Commission sent warning letters to 25 companies that market health plans or sell leads for them on October 29, three days before Marketplace open enrollment begins November 1. The same day, the agency’s consumer staff reminded the public that prerecorded robocalls selling health insurance are already illegal. The letters accuse no one of anything, but they put an industry on notice just as the phones and feeds fill with pitches.
The recipients advertise Affordable Care Act Marketplace plans and other products, such as limited indemnity plans and medical discount programs, or generate sales leads for the firms that do. The FTC says it expects to send more letters on a rolling basis, so 25 is a first batch rather than a final count.
The robocall rule is not new
In a consumer alert published the same day, FTC staff wrote that it is illegal to robocall people with prerecorded messages marketing health insurance. The alert adds that a company calling that way is likely a scammer or someone a consumer may not want to do business with. Nothing about that rule changed on October 29; the agency simply restated it ahead of the busiest shopping window.
The same alert lists other warning signs. Ads may promise “comprehensive health insurance” while offering limited benefits, and some are for medical discount cards, which are not health insurance. Others look like they come from the government or a well-known insurer but are sent by impersonators, and they turn up in paid search results, on social media, in texts and on the phone.
For anyone shopping the Marketplace this fall, including early retirees who are not yet on Medicare and people whose job coverage has ended, the practical test is how the pitch arrives. A recorded voice selling a plan breaks the rule before it makes a single claim about benefits. The FTC’s advice is to start at HealthCare.gov or call the Marketplace Call Center at 1-800-318-2596 instead of answering a call or clicking an ad.
Retirement deadlines, in your inbox: Miss an enrollment or claim deadline and the money can be gone. Join the Retirement Money Brief and we’ll send you our Scam & Identity-Theft Action Card as a welcome gift.
Get the Brief + the scam action card →
We may earn a commission from links on this page.
What the 25 letters tell marketers
According to the FTC’s announcement, the letters name four kinds of conduct that may violate the law. They are misrepresenting a plan’s benefits or limits, presenting a plan as major or comprehensive medical insurance when it is not, misstating what a plan costs, and falsely promising free offers, cash rewards, rebates or other incentives to people who enroll.
Christopher Mufarrige, director of the FTC’s Bureau of Consumer Protection, said the letters “remind companies that open enrollment is not an invitation to misrepresent what their plans actually cover.” He also called making healthcare more transparent and affordable a top priority for the agency.
The letters point to earlier FTC cases in this market: Top Healthcare Options Insurance Agency in January 2026, Innovative Partners in April 2026, Assurance IQ and MediaAlpha in August 2025, Simple Health Plans in February 2024 and Benefytt Technologies in August 2022. They tell recipients to review their advertisements for compliance and say the FTC is closely monitoring the marketplace for unlawful conduct.
A warning letter is not a complaint. The FTC states plainly that the letters do not allege wrongdoing by any recipient, which means the 25 companies are being told where the line sits, not accused of crossing it. Any company that ignores the notice and later misleads shoppers would face an agency that has already put its expectations in writing.
Discount cards and lead generators
The letters went to two kinds of businesses. Marketers sell plans or products directly. Lead generators run ads and web forms, collect the names and phone numbers of people who respond, and pass that contact information to sellers.
That chain matters most for the products the FTC singled out beyond Marketplace insurance. A medical discount program offers reduced prices at participating providers and does not pay claims, and a limited indemnity plan pays set amounts for covered events rather than the cost of care. The alert’s warning is that an ad for either can be written to sound like full coverage.
Dates that set the pace of the pitches
HealthCare.gov’s dates page sets open enrollment for 2027 coverage from November 1 to January 15. People who enroll or change plans by December 15 get coverage starting January 1, and those who act between December 16 and January 15 get coverage starting February 1, as long as the first premium is paid.
Because the window runs about two and a half months, the pitches do not stop after the first week. The December 15 cutoff gives sellers a natural deadline to lean on, and the FTC’s message to consumers is that urgency in a cold call or an ad is a reason to slow down and go to the official site.
Anyone who gets a prerecorded insurance call or sees an ad that looks misleading can report it at ReportFraud.ftc.gov. The FTC’s Consumer Response Center also takes reports at 877-382-4357.
The two October 29 notices split the problem in a useful way. The letters go after what a plan claims to be, and the robocall rule goes after how the pitch reaches a household. A call that fails the second test has already shown who is on the line, whatever the plan on offer is called.
Getting pitches already?
A recorded sales call is usually the first move in a longer play. The caller wants a name, a date of birth, a Social Security number or a bank login, and open enrollment gives that request a believable reason.
Scam-Proof Your Accounts in a Weekend covers the steps that make a stolen detail less useful: how to freeze credit at all three bureaus, free by federal law, and how to lock bank logins with two-step login, alerts and a verbal password. It also includes a family code word for fake grandchild-in-trouble calls and a first-hour plan if a scam gets through anyway.
Get the credit-freeze and bank-lock steps in one weekend guide →
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
