Ohio Medicare Advantage members whose current plan will no longer be available beginning Jan. 1 automatically get a Special Enrollment Period that runs from Dec. 8 through the end of February, the Ohio Department of Insurance said in a Nov. 2 bulletin. The same notice says people who return to Original Medicare have up to 63 days of guaranteed rights to buy certain Medigap plans, even with health conditions.
The department’s wording is plain: “Some Ohioans are learning that their current Medicare Advantage plan will no longer be available beginning Jan. 1.” Plans that are ending must mail non-renewal notices, which the bulletin says typically go out by Oct. 1. Anyone holding one of those letters is the person these two protections are written for.
Two enrollment windows for a plan that is not coming back
Medicare’s yearly open enrollment runs Oct. 15 through Dec. 7, and the department’s bulletin urges Ohioans to compare their 2027 options before it closes. People with a non-renewal letter can pick a replacement plan in that window like anyone else. The special period opens Dec. 8, the day after open enrollment ends, and gives a second chance.
Medicare’s own page on special enrollment periods lists the same dates for a plan whose contract is not renewed: Dec. 8 through the last day of February. The window covers Medicare Advantage plans, Medicare drug plans and Medicare Cost Plans, so a person who lost a drug-only plan gets the same extra time.
For Ohioans with a non-renewal letter, the decision is whether to choose a new plan before Dec. 7 or wait for the Dec. 8 window. Waiting leaves the new plan’s start to the month after enrollment, according to the department, while choosing during open enrollment lines up with a Jan. 1 start. Anyone unsure which route fits should compare the 2027 plans on Medicare.gov before the 7th.
Retirement deadlines, in your inbox: Miss an enrollment or claim deadline and the money can be gone. Join the Retirement Money Brief and we’ll send you our 2027 Medicare Plan-Change Checklist as a welcome gift.
Get the Brief + the plan-change checklist →
We may earn a commission from links on this page.
Doing nothing has a default. Medicare’s page says people are enrolled in Original Medicare if they do not join another Medicare Advantage plan before the current plan ends. That means a member who ignores the letter does not simply lose coverage on Jan. 1, but lands in Original Medicare without the extras a Medicare Advantage plan may have carried.
The Medigap guarantee and its 63-day clock
People who go back to Original Medicare have a guaranteed right to buy certain Medicare Supplement plans, known as Medigap, even if they have health conditions. A Medigap policy is sold by a private insurer and fills in part of what Original Medicare leaves unpaid, such as deductibles and coinsurance.
The department says the protection “lasts for up to 63 days after their Medicare Advantage coverage ends.” For a plan that ends Dec. 31, that clock reaches into early March 2027. The special enrollment period closes at the end of February, so the Medigap window outlasts it by several days.
That gap in timing is useful for anyone who wants to leave Medicare Advantage altogether. A person can apply for a Medigap policy while the right still applies, then add a standalone drug plan inside the special period. The bulletin lists prescription drug plans among the choices that period opens.
Ohio’s Medicare Supplement page says every policy must be labeled “Medicare Supplement Insurance” and sold under letter designations, each with the same basic benefits. Comparing two insurers’ Plan G, for example, is mostly a comparison of price and service, not of coverage.
Ohio’s Medicare Advantage market is shrinking
The Ohio notices are part of a wider pullback. Becker’s Payer, a trade publication, counted 212 Medicare Advantage plans in Ohio for 2026 and 180 for 2027, a drop of 32. Plan counts fall in 29 of 51 jurisdictions, according to the same analysis, and as many as 2.9 million enrollees nationally had to find new coverage for 2026.
A smaller menu does not mean every member is affected. The department says only “some Ohioans” are losing a plan. Members whose own plan is continuing do not get the special period or the Medigap guarantee on that basis.
Free counseling and a scam to avoid
The department runs the Ohio Senior Health Insurance Information Program, called OSHIIP, which describes itself as “free, objective, Medicare health insurance information, one-on-one counseling, and more.” The Medicare line is 800-686-1578, and counseling appointments can be booked on insurance.ohio.gov.
OSHIIP also hosts Medicare Checkup events. The bulletin lists a webinar on Nov. 13, and in-person sessions are scheduled for Nov. 9 at the Muskingum County Center for Seniors in Zanesville and the Marion County Council on Aging.
The bulletin also carries a fraud alert from Pro Seniors, Ohio’s Senior Medicare Patrol. It says callers have claimed to be from government agencies about a “$90 Medicare premium rebate,” sometimes offering gifts for switching plans. Medicare never calls to sell products or enroll someone unless contacted first, and suspected fraud can be reported to Pro Seniors at 800-293-4767.
Put together, the calendar is short. A non-renewal letter arrives by Oct. 1, open enrollment closes Dec. 7, the special period runs Dec. 8 through February, and the Medigap guarantee runs about 63 days past the plan’s end. Each of those dates belongs to the same person, and missing the first does not close the rest.
The costliest mistake is letting the Medigap window lapse without a decision. A person who leaves Medicare Advantage in March, after the right has ended, no longer has the department’s assurance that an insurer must accept the application despite health conditions. Anyone leaning toward Original Medicare should settle that question while the clock is running.
Holding an Ohio non-renewal letter?
The stake is a one-time Medigap right that lasts 63 days after a Medicare Advantage plan ends, plus an enrollment window that closes at the end of February. Members who sort out the choice late can end up with a plan that does not fit their doctors or their drugs.
The Medicare Money Bundle puts all 8 Medicare guides in one download, with large print. Two of them speak to this decision: Open Enrollment in an Afternoon, which covers the Plan Finder in one sitting and ends in a keep-or-switch answer, and Medigap vs. Medicare Advantage, which sets out Medigap rights, state rules and both paths priced.
Get the Medigap vs. Advantage guide and the plan-finder walkthrough in one download →
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.