Skip to main content

The Money Overview

Postal inspectors advise black ink on mailed checks, and FinCEN found altered checks in about 44% of the mail-theft check fraud reports it reviewed from 2023

Postal inspectors tell customers who mail checks to write them in black ink, leave no blank spaces and drop them in the slot inside a post office, and federal data shows why. The Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, or FinCEN, found that altered checks made up about 44% of the mail-theft check fraud reports it reviewed for a six-month stretch in 2023. A thief who steals a check from a mailbox usually changes the payee and the amount, then deposits it.

The rules below are evergreen and apply to anyone who still pays rent, a contractor or a grandchild’s birthday gift by paper check. The figures carry the year the agencies state.

What postal inspectors say to do before mailing

The Postal Inspection Service’s check fraud handout lists a short set of habits. Use indelible black ink, which is harder to wash off, and leave no blank spaces on the payee or amount lines. Do not write a Social Security number, credit card information, a driver’s license number or a phone number on a check.

For the mail itself, the inspectors say to pick up delivered mail promptly and not leave it in the mailbox overnight, use security envelopes and drop mail in the letter slots inside a post office. Customers who travel can ask the post office to hold their mail, and Informed Delivery at USPS.com sends daily email notices of incoming mail.

After a check is mailed, the handout says to confirm with the payee that it arrived. People who pay by check can also review bank activity and check images in mobile or online banking, and make sure the endorsement on the back matches the intended payee. The handout suggests e-checks, ACH automatic payments or other electronic payments as alternatives.

Stay ahead of bank account and debt news: Miss an enrollment or claim deadline and the money can be gone. Join the Retirement Money Brief, one email every weekday from Ellen at RetireShield, and we’ll send you our Bank, Debt & Protected-Benefit Checkup as a welcome gift.

Get the Brief + the bank checkup →

We may earn a commission from links on this page.

How a stolen check gets altered

FinCEN’s trend analysis of check fraud covers reports banks and other financial firms filed between Feb. 27 and Aug. 31, 2023. It counts 15,417 reports on mail theft-related check fraud tied to about $688 million in transactions, some of which may be attempts. The average report involved $44,774 and the median $14,215.

Banks filed 13,618 of those reports, or 88%, and credit unions filed 882. FinCEN’s review sorted the schemes into three types. Altered checks were about 44%, counterfeit checks about 26% and fraudulently signed checks, including forged endorsements, about 20%.

Check washing is one way to alter a check. FinCEN describes it as a moderately sophisticated method in which chemicals remove the original ink so new information can be written in. The payee and the amount are the most often changed fields.

A counterfeit check works differently. The thief uses a stolen check as a template to print new ones carrying the victim’s account and routing numbers, which is why a check that was never altered can still drain an account.

Why mailboxes are the target

FinCEN’s analysis cites Postal Inspection Service and Postal Service figures from earlier years. From March 2020 to February 2021 the inspection service received 299,020 mail theft complaints, 161% more than in the prior 12 months. Between October 2021 and October 2022 the Postal Service reported 38,500 high-volume mail theft incidents from mail receptacles, and 412 mail carriers were robbed on duty.

In the first half of the 2023 fiscal year it reported more than 25,000 such incidents and 305 carriers robbed. FinCEN also reports it received more than 680,000 filings on check fraud of every kind in 2022, nearly double the prior year. These are the agencies’ own counts, and each belongs to the period shown.

When a forged check clears the account

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau says in an Ask CFPB answer, last reviewed Aug. 22, 2024, that a customer is generally not responsible for a fraudulent endorsement as long as it is reported within the period set by state law. The page sets no fixed number of days, so the state’s period controls.

If the check was processed as an electronic transfer, the same page says additional federal protections apply. Otherwise state law applies. The CFPB advises contacting the bank or credit union as soon as the forgery is discovered, and it takes complaints at 855-411-2372 and at consumerfinance.gov/complaint.

The federal site HelpWithMyBank.gov describes the practical side. It says a customer generally has up to 30 days from the statement date to notify the bank of an error, including an unauthorized signature or alteration, and that the bank will generally require an affidavit saying the check was not authorized. It may also ask for a police report.

That site also warns that a bank may argue the forgery resulted from the customer’s own negligence, and that the deposit account agreement governs the outcome. A customer who sees an altered check on a statement should read the agreement for its time limit and notify the bank in writing within it.

The same page recommends reviewing periodic statements regularly, and says that when stolen checks produce several forgeries, closing the account can be worth considering. Neither the CFPB nor HelpWithMyBank.gov states a single federal deadline that applies to every check, so the shortest window usually is the one in the deposit agreement.

Where to report a stolen or altered check

The inspection service says a customer whose check was stolen or altered should request copies of the fraudulent checks from the bank and give law enforcement those copies along with details about the bank of first deposit. If the check was mailed, the handout says to record how, when and where it was sent, because those details help identify where in the mail stream it was taken.

Reports go to the Postal Inspection Service at uspis.gov or 1-877-876-2455, and the local bank should be told as well. The handout notes that stolen or altered checks are bank fraud under 18 U.S.C. 1344, which carries a fine of up to $1,000,000, up to 30 years in prison, or both.

The practical order is the bank first, since the window for reporting an error can be as short as 30 days from the statement date, then the inspection service, then the police. Keeping the envelope, the receipt or tracking record and the dates of the mailing gives all three something to work from.

Still paying by paper check?

A thief with a stolen check has a routing number, an account number and a signature to copy, and the 30-day clock for reporting errors starts with the statement, not the theft. The people hit hardest are the ones who do not look at statements until the money is already gone.

Scam-Proof Your Accounts in a Weekend shows how to lock bank logins with two-step login, alerts and a verbal password, so a withdrawal or an odd check gets noticed fast. It does not recover money from a forged check or replace a report to the bank.

The guide also includes the first-hour plan if a scam gets through anyway, in a large-print edition.

Get the bank-login lock guide and first-hour plan for check fraud →

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.


More in Bank Accounts & Fees