Skip to main content

The Money Overview

Credit Acceptance must tell borrowers in writing within 10 days that service contracts and GAP are optional and cancelable, its New York settlement order says

Car buyers whose loans are held by Credit Acceptance Corporation must get a written reminder within 10 days that any vehicle service contract or GAP product on the loan is optional and can be canceled, the company’s New York settlement order says. The rule is one piece of a roughly $700 million multistate deal announced Sept. 17, 2026, and the order’s effective date is Nov. 2, 2026.

The practical question for anyone with a Credit Acceptance loan is whether a service contract or GAP coverage is folded into the payment, and whether it was ever wanted. Attorneys general allege that some borrowers did not know they were buying these products or were led to believe they had to take them to get financing. The order now requires the company to tell borrowers in writing that the products can be canceled and how to reach the company to do it.

Stay ahead of settlement and refund news: Miss an enrollment or claim deadline and the money can be gone. Join the Retirement Money Brief, one email every weekday from Ellen at RetireShield, and we’ll send you our Open Settlements & Refund Tracker as a welcome gift.

Get the Brief + the settlements tracker →

We may earn a commission from links on this page.

The written notice after a loan changes hands

Credit Acceptance finances purchases made at dealerships, and the order’s clock starts when the company accepts a loan contract from the dealer. Under paragraph 23(b) of the New York consent order, the company must notify and remind each consumer in writing within 10 days of that moment. The notice has to name the products, state their cost, say they can be canceled and explain how to contact the company.

Two products are covered. A vehicle service contract is a paid repair plan, and guaranteed asset protection, known as GAP, covers the difference between a loan balance and a car’s value after a total loss. The order defines both as products the company finances, which means the price is rolled into the loan balance rather than paid at the counter.

Before the loan exists, dealers that use the company’s approval software must hand over a separate consent form. It has to list each product, state that it is optional and show the monthly and total payment with and without it, and the consumer must sign before the retail installment contract is executed. The company may not make a product a condition of financing.

The order also says consumers must be informed in writing, after the loan is made, of the products they financed and their optional nature. The reminder comes after the signing, so a borrower who rushed through the paperwork at the dealership gets a second chance to catch a product that was never wanted.

Canceling without giving up the car

New York Attorney General Letitia James’s office says the company must contact consumers outside the dealer showroom to explain any add-on products they bought, and must offer a process to cancel them while keeping the vehicle. James said Credit Acceptance, which the release calls CAC, “preyed on consumers in New York and across the nation with false promises of affordable loans.” The office announced the deal in a Sept. 17 release.

Paragraphs 23(g) through 23(j) set the mechanics. The company must provide a “simple, clear, and easy-to-access method” to cancel, record the reason when a consumer says the product was presented as required, and allow cancellation through the company itself, including issuing or arranging rebates and refunds. Cancellations must be “promptly applied,” and the company must confirm each one and explain any change to the payment.

Timing changes the math. If the account is current, or the cancellation comes within 30 days after the loan began, the balance is re-amortized and the monthly payment recalculated. A canceled product therefore adjusts the payment schedule as well as the balance, which matters to borrowers on a fixed budget.

Dealers face monitoring too. The company must track sales penetration rates, cancellation rates and consumer complaints, and must investigate when two or more accounts from a single dealer in a 12-month period show related cancellations or complaints. If a dealer is found to have imposed a product the consumer never wanted, the company must backdate the cancellation to the day the loan began.

What the order does not promise

The order sets no refund amount and no refund deadline. It requires only that the company issue or arrange the rebates and refunds that a cancellation produces. Borrowers who want a dollar figure need the product’s own contract and the company’s confirmation of the cancellation, which the order requires it to send.

The order gives the company six months from the court’s entry of the order to put these add-on procedures in place, with monthly updates until then. It also requires the company to keep add-on complaints, cancellation data and related phone calls for five years, which leaves a trail for state auditors.

Where the debt relief stands

The add-on rules sit beside the headline relief. The company agreed to wipe out debt for more than 55,000 consumers, more than $630 million in all, plus $60 million in restitution for people who lost cars within months of taking a loan, New York’s release says. California’s announcement lists the covered loans as those made from Nov. 1, 2015 through Nov. 30, 2025, with the debt relief due on or before Nov. 2, 2026.

For loans made from December 2025, the order adds what California calls an off ramp. Colorado’s attorney general says qualifying failing loans get 95% debt relief and five years of protection from collection lawsuits, and Minnesota’s attorney general describes the same 12 or 18 month default windows, depending on the loan’s risk.

Nobody has to apply. Colorado says the company notifies borrowers who get debt relief and a claims administrator notifies those owed restitution. Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison’s release lists (651) 296-3353 and (800) 657-3787 for complaints to his office.

For borrowers, the add-on notice is the one piece of this settlement that asks something of them. Debt relief and restitution arrive without a form, but a service contract or GAP charge stays on the loan until someone cancels it. The order makes the route easy to find, and the borrower still decides whether the product is worth keeping.

Got a service contract or GAP on a Credit Acceptance loan?

A settlement letter carries dates that decide what a borrower can still do: when notice went out, when the relief lands, when a window closes. In the Credit Acceptance deal, debt relief was due by Nov. 2, 2026, the add-on notice follows a 10-day clock and the court’s schedule runs six months, and a borrower holding a letter can lose track of which date applies.

The Settlement & Refund Recovery System from RetireShield teaches the four-date rule for reading a settlement notice, so each letter gets sorted by what it says and when. It is a private RetireShield product, not a government program, and it does not cancel anything or file anything for the reader.

Inside is a claim log and payment tracker for writing down each letter, each call to the company and each confirmation, the same paper trail the order expects a cancellation to leave.

Get the four-date notice rule and a claim log for settlement letters →

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.


More in Loans & Lending