Skip to main content

The Money Overview

Florida Medicare Advantage enrollees lose 51 plans for 2027, and Lee Health’s UnitedHealthcare contract ends Dec. 31 in Fort Myers and Cape Coral

Florida Medicare Advantage enrollees will have 51 fewer plans to choose from in 2027, with the state’s count falling from 611 to 560, and UnitedHealthcare members in Lee County face a second loss on Dec. 31, when Lee Health’s contracts with the insurer end. The drop is the largest of any state. Medicare’s annual enrollment period runs Oct. 15 to Dec. 7, 2026.

Becker’s Payer reported in late September that Florida is “losing the most plans overall, falling from 611 in 2026 to 560 in 2027.” Ohio is next at 212 to 180 plans, followed by Illinois at 157 to 136. The Florida figure is a net count: plans that insurers add are already subtracted from the plans they cut.

People on a Florida Medicare Advantage plan have two separate questions to settle before Dec. 7. The first is whether the plan on the card is being renewed at all. The second, for UnitedHealthcare members in Lee County, is whether Fort Myers and Cape Coral hospitals and doctors will still be in network on Jan. 1, because a plan that renews can still lose its hospitals.

Retirement deadlines, in your inbox: Miss an enrollment or claim deadline and the money can be gone. Join the Retirement Money Brief and we’ll send you our 2027 Medicare Plan-Change Checklist as a welcome gift.

Get the Brief + the plan-change checklist →

We may earn a commission from links on this page.

Where Florida’s plans went

Becker’s Payer, in a Sept. 28 report by Jakob Emerson, ranked Florida first among the states for plans lost in 2027. Florida Trend, which covered the same count Oct. 20, described insurers pulling out of underperforming counties.

The Florida Trend report names Humana and UnitedHealthcare as two insurers eliminating some plans or moving others from PPOs to HMOs. It points to rising care costs and shrinking profits as the reasons.

UnitedHealthcare’s provider site says the insurer is making service-area changes to its Medicare Advantage plans effective Jan. 1, 2027, and that non-renewal notices to members are dated Oct. 2, 2026. A member who got one of those letters has a plan that will not exist in the new year, so staying put is not an option.

A cut plan and a shrunken network are different problems. When a plan ends, the member needs a new one for Jan. 1. When a plan stays but a hospital system leaves, the member keeps the plan and loses access to those doctors, which a renewal letter does not warn about.

The count matters beyond Florida’s size. A state with fewer plans has fewer fallback options when one plan’s network shrinks, and Florida’s lead in plan losses means members in some counties may find that the plan matching their doctors is one of those no longer sold.

Lee Health and UnitedHealthcare

Lee Health, the system behind Lee Memorial Hospital in Fort Myers and Cape Coral Hospital, told patients in an open letter that it will end its hospital and physician contracts with UnitedHealthcare at the end of 2026, Becker’s Hospital Review reported Aug. 28. Out-of-network status begins Jan. 1, 2027, and covers employer, individual and Medicare Advantage plans.

The letter says about one-third of Lee Health’s medical-necessity denials are tied to UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage plans, and it alleges the insurer owes more than $100 million in disputed and underpaid claims. “Lee Health and UnitedHealthcare have fundamentally different priorities,” the letter says.

UnitedHealthcare’s Lee Health page, updated Nov. 3, says no agreement is in place. The insurer says it sent Lee Health a proposal on Oct. 30 to keep long-term network access for its commercial and Medicare Advantage plans, and it describes Lee Health as unwilling to engage in good-faith talks. Lee Health’s side of that exchange is in its open letter.

Medicare Supplement plans are not affected, according to the same page. People with a Medicare Supplement, or Medigap, policy from UnitedHealthcare keep access to Lee Health’s hospitals and physicians whatever happens to the Medicare Advantage contract. Medigap is a separate policy that pays costs left over after Original Medicare.

What UnitedHealthcare members in Lee County can do

The insurer says members can apply for continuity of care at any time up to 30 days after a provider leaves the network, and that the request needs approval. Members who are mid-treatment, scheduled for surgery or on a standing course of care are the ones most likely to need it.

The page says a dedicated advocate team is available through the number on the health plan ID card. The page lists no separate phone number, so the card is the starting point for any question about a specific doctor or hospital.

Waiting for a deal carries a date. A member who stays in a UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage plan hoping for a settlement has until Dec. 7 to move to a plan that Lee Health accepts. Members who wait past that date for news of a deal will be holding whatever plan they had on the last day of the window.

Sorting out a 2027 choice before Dec. 7

Medicare’s Plan Finder shows the plans sold in each ZIP code with premiums, drug costs and star ratings. With 51 fewer plans statewide, the list for a given ZIP code can look different from last year’s, and the plan a member used in 2026 may not appear.

The doctor check matters as much as the premium check. A plan that looks cheaper on paper can leave a Fort Myers or Cape Coral patient without the local hospital system, and a lower premium can disappear in a single specialist referral. Plan Finder results show a plan’s costs, and the doctor and hospital question still goes to the plan or the provider.

Free, unbiased counseling is available through Florida’s SHINE program, reached through the state Elder Helpline at 1-800-963-5337. SHINE counselors do not sell insurance, which matters in a season when agents and mailers are everywhere.

The window does not fully close on Dec. 7. Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment runs Jan. 1 to Mar. 31, 2027, for people already in a Medicare Advantage plan, and it allows one change. It cannot be used to join a Medicare Advantage plan for the first time, and it comes after a month of out-of-network bills if the hospital has already left.

For many Florida members, the 51-plan drop and the Lee Health split look like two stories and are one decision. The plan has to exist, the hospital has to be in its network, and both have to be true on Jan. 1, with Dec. 7 as the last day to make them so.

Will the Fort Myers hospital still be in network on Jan. 1?

A member who misses one detail, a nonrenewal letter in the mail or a hospital that leaves the network, can end up with a plan that does not cover the care already scheduled. Dec. 7 is the last day to change that for 2027.

The Medicare Money Bundle puts all eight Medicare guides in one download, with large print. Open Enrollment in an Afternoon walks through Plan Finder in one sitting and ends with a keep-or-switch answer, and Medigap vs. Medicare Advantage covers Medigap rights, state rules, and both paths priced.

Alongside those two guides come Extra Help and Medicare Savings Programs, the drug-cost guide and the billing-error and late-penalty guides, so one download covers what comes after the plan is chosen.

Get the Plan Finder walkthrough and Medigap-versus-Advantage guide for the Dec. 7 choice →

This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.


More in Social Security & Medicare