Retirees and surviving spouses in Howard University’s frozen pension plan are in line for permanent monthly increases and a lump sum under a $1.3 million class settlement that won preliminary court approval on Sept. 18. The deal covers about 1,788 plan participants and beneficiaries. Final approval is still ahead, with a fairness hearing expected on or after Dec. 18, 2026.
The money traces to a lawsuit over how Howard converted pension checks for married retirees, not to a change in the benefit formula. The Howard University Employees’ Retirement Plan was set up in 1976 and frozen in 2010, so nobody earns new credit, but thousands of people still draw monthly payments from it.
A 1984 mortality table and a 7% rate
When a retiree picks a joint and survivor annuity, the plan starts from the single-life payment and reduces it so the check can continue to a spouse after the retiree dies. Federal law says that joint annuity must be the “actuarial equivalent” of a single annuity for the life of the participant. The assumptions behind the reduction decide how big the monthly check is.
Stephen Whetstone, a former director of academic information resources at Howard, sued on Aug. 17, 2023 for a class of retirees and survivors. The defendants were the university, the plan, its retirement plan committee and 10 committee members. Siri & Glimstad LLP of New York represented the retirees.
The complaint said the plan used the Uninsured Pensioners 1984 mortality table, which it described as built on 1960s and 1970s data, along with a 7% interest rate. Plaintiffs argued those inputs were outdated and left benefits understated. Howard agreed to settle before a court had to decide whether the plan’s assumptions were reasonable.
The lead plaintiff’s numbers show the gap per person. He worked at Howard about 14 years and retired at 70, and his joint annuity paid $584.73 a month. Using current Treasury Department assumptions, he said it should have paid $602.72, a difference of $17.99 a month that continues for life.
The class covers retired Howard employees and beneficiaries receiving joint and survivor annuities or preretirement survivor annuities, so a retiree who took a single-life annuity is not the group the lawsuit targeted. Anyone in the plan should find the annuity form and first-payment date on their pension paperwork, and keep any class notice that arrives, because it will state the objection date and who handles payments.
Stay ahead of settlement and refund news: Miss an enrollment or claim deadline and the money can be gone. Join the Retirement Money Brief and we’ll send you our Open Settlements & Refund Tracker as a welcome gift.
Get the Brief + the settlements tracker →
We may earn a commission from links on this page.
The court said the law on actuarial equivalence is “largely unsettled,” with federal circuits divided on whether ERISA, the federal pension law, requires plan assumptions to be reasonable. It also noted a trial would have meant a “costly ‘battle of the experts’.” Judge Loren AliKhan received the retirees’ request for preliminary approval of the class settlement.
Two tiers for splitting the money
The $1.3 million settlement divides the class into two groups. People whose annuity payments started on or after Aug. 17, 2017, share 75% of the net amount, allocated by each person’s estimated underpayment. That date is six years before the lawsuit was filed.
People whose payments started earlier share the other 25%, allocated by current benefit levels. The retirees’ lawyers describe the two-tier approach as a response to how hard it is to rebuild benefits calculated across several decades. Some benefits are reserved for people whose payments began between 1995 and 2017.
The relief comes in two forms: permanent monthly pension increases and a lump sum covering the stretch between final approval and the date the higher checks begin. The increases must start within 150 days of final approval. Plaintiffs’ actuary estimated recoveries of about 30.8% for one group and 18.2% for the other.
Spread across the whole class, $1.3 million averages roughly $727 per participant before court-approved costs. Because most of the value arrives as a permanent increase, the real benefit to any one household depends on age, annuity form and start date. A survivor annuity that began in 2018 and one that began in 2003 land in different tiers.
What stands between approval and the first higher check
Preliminary approval means the court found the deal worth sending to class members for reaction. It does not make the money final. The hearing is expected on or after Dec. 18, 2026, so the date can slip, and the monthly increases cannot start until the judge signs off.
Class members keep the right to object at that hearing, and no objection deadline appears in the public summaries of the deal. Those summaries describe payments divided by each person’s benefit data and mention no claim form. The court-approved notice sent to class members will say whether any step is required and by when.
Anyone in the class who has not received a notice by mail can ask the plan office or class counsel for it before the hearing. Settlement mail is easy to mistake for junk, and the notice is the only place the objection date, the final hearing date and the payment administrator are spelled out.
For the 1,788 people in the class, the timeline is long. A hearing in the second half of December is the earliest point, and the higher checks have 150 days after that to begin. If final approval came on Dec. 18, that window would run to mid-May 2027, so the first increase could arrive well into next year.
Drawing a Howard survivor annuity?
With a fairness hearing expected on or after Dec. 18 and a class notice that may not have reached every household, timing is the part retirees lose track of. The objection date, the hearing date and the payment date sit in different parts of the same notice, and a missed one cannot be recovered.
The Settlement & Refund Recovery System teaches the four-date rule for reading a settlement notice, so those dates land on one calendar. It also includes a claim log and payment tracker, which keeps each settlement, its status and any money received in one place.
The package comes with a 5-tab Excel tracker pre-filled with all 51 state unclaimed-property offices, plus a large-print quick-start sheet for anyone who prefers paper.
Get the four-date notice rule and a payment tracker for the Howard retiree settlement →
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.