Skip to main content

The Money Overview

Tuna settlement checks could not be cashed, and the administrator mailed replacements on Sept. 28 with an extra $20

Some class members in the packaged-tuna antitrust settlement could not cash the checks mailed to them in September, and JND Legal Administration, the claims administrator, mailed replacements on Sept. 28 with an extra $20 added to each. The administrator attributes the failure to a bank processing issue that the bank has since resolved, and says replacements went only to affected class members. The episode touches a $152.2 million consumer fund whose claim window closed at the end of 2024, so the only live question for recipients is what to do when two checks for the same payment exist.


Four dates on a settlement notice: Only one of them is the deadline that matters, and the other three are what make people miss it. The four-date rule in The Settlement & Refund Recovery System sorts them.

See the four-date rule in The Settlement & Refund Recovery System →

What JND says went wrong with the tuna checks, and what the $20 covers

The administrator’s notice on the settlement website states that “some class members were unable to cash their checks due to a Bank processing issue, which the Bank has now resolved.” The notice gives no count of affected checks, names no bank and does not describe what failed in the processing. It frames the problem as a fault in the payment channel rather than anything about the class members who held the checks.

Replacements were mailed on Sept. 28, 2026, and the notice says checks “were only reissued to affected Class Members.” A class member whose original check cleared therefore received no second payment, and no extra $20. The administrator’s FAQ adds that each replacement was sent to the same address as the original check, so a recipient who has moved since the claim was filed faces the same delivery gap that existed the first time.

Each replacement “included an additional $20 as a courtesy to help offset bank fees incurred,” in the notice’s words. The amount is flat. Where a recipient’s bank charged more than that, the FAQ tells the recipient to email documentation of the fees to the administrator for review, though the page does not say what reimbursement, if any, that review can produce.

Why the original checks should stay out of the bank

The notice carries a direct instruction: “Do not attempt to re-deposit the original check, as doing so may result in additional fees.” The stated reason is cost, not fraud. A second deposit attempt on a check the bank has already failed to process can trigger another round of the very fees the $20 courtesy was meant to cover, which turns a goodwill payment into a net loss for anyone who tries it.

The wording leaves one point open. The notice says re-depositing risks fees but does not say whether the original checks have been formally voided, and it does not describe what the issuing bank does if one arrives. For a recipient holding both paper checks, the practical sorting is therefore simple: the replacement is the instrument with a live clock, and the original is the one the administrator wants left alone.

The FAQ puts a number on that clock. Replacement checks “have a new 60-day deadline to deposit or cash the checks,” and the same page says payments for approved claims first went out on Sept. 8, 2026. Those payments were pro rata, based on the volume of cans and pouches in each valid claim, and no payment was made where a class member’s total came to less than $5.00. The administrator publishes no average payment, so how the flat $20 compares with a typical check is not shown.

A closed claim window, a $152.2 million fund and six named defendants

The checks stem from In re Packaged Seafood Products Antitrust Litigation, No. 15-MD-2670 in the Southern District of California. The notice lists the defendants as StarKist, DWI, Lion, Bumble Bee, Chicken of the Sea and Thai Union Group, and puts the consumer settlement fund at $152.2 million. JND Legal Administration runs the distribution, with a phone line at 866-615-0977 and an email address, info@TunaEndPurchaserSettlement.com, listed for questions.

This is not a claim story. The deadline to file was Dec. 31, 2024, and the notice states that anyone who did not file by then will not receive a payment. The September checks and the Sept. 28 replacements went to people whose claims were already approved, which is why the administrator’s notice calls for no action beyond leaving the original check undeposited.

The route differs from government-run refunds. The FTC’s index of recent cases resulting in refunds lists active programs in a table with a contact for each case. The tuna fund came from a private class action run by JND, so questions about a missing or uncashed check go to the court-appointed administrator and its dedicated line, not to a federal agency.

Two paper checks, a 60-day replacement clock and the fee-documentation route

The friction in this episode is narrow and specific. A recipient may hold an original check that must not be deposited and a replacement that must be, and the only date the administrator’s FAQ attaches to the replacement is the new 60-day window. A replacement set aside and forgotten becomes the same uncashed-check problem a second time, this time without a further courtesy payment promised anywhere on the page.

The second wrinkle is the fee ceiling. The $20 is fixed, while bank fees are not, and the FAQ’s route for larger charges depends on the recipient producing documentation of what the bank actually charged. The page does not say how long a review takes or what standard it applies, so recipients with fees above $20 are working from an incomplete description of the process.

The official route is the administrator’s own: the notice page, the FAQ, the 866-615-0977 line and the settlement email address, none of which costs anything to use.


Replacement checks and the dates that follow them

A reissued settlement check restarts a deadline that the original payment had already started. Recipients who hold more than one payment from different cases can lose track of which date belongs to which check.

The Settlement & Refund Recovery System explains how to get an expired or uncashed settlement check reissued and gives a claim log and payment tracker for recording which payment arrived and when.

Log each settlement check and its deposit deadline in the payment tracker →

This article was researched and drafted with the assistance of AI and reviewed by The Money Overview editorial team.

Avatar photo

Daniel Harper

Daniel is a finance writer covering personal finance topics including budgeting, credit, and beginner investing. He began his career contributing to his Substack, where he covered consumer finance trends and practical money topics for everyday readers. Since then, he has written for a range of personal finance blogs and fintech platforms, focusing on clear, straightforward content that helps readers make more informed financial decisions.​


More in Smart Spending