A federal benefit check of $850 does not lose 15 percent to a Treasury offset. It loses $100. The reason sits in the Treasury regulation itself, which sets the amount taken from a monthly payment at the smallest of three figures, and for a payment only modestly above $750 the dollar floor produces a smaller number than the percentage does. On $850, 15 percent would be $127.50, so the floor saves $27.50 a month. The distinction matters because the common shorthand, that the government takes 15 percent, is wrong for a whole band of recipients.
The rule is 31 CFR 285.4, administered by Treasury through its Bureau of the Fiscal Service, and its own worked examples carry the arithmetic. They were last amended on January 12, 2016, so the percentage and the floor have stood for years. What changes from one recipient to the next is which of the three tests ends up binding: the size of the debt, the percentage ceiling, or the amount by which the payment exceeds $750.
The lesser-of-three test inside 31 CFR 285.4
Under the Treasury regulation, the amount offset from a monthly covered benefit payment is the lesser of the debt, including interest, penalties and administrative costs; an amount equal to 15% of the monthly covered benefit payment; or the amount, if any, by which the payment exceeds $750. The third prong is the floor. Nothing in the first $750 of a monthly payment can be reached, and only the portion above it is exposed.
The regulation illustrates the point with three payments. At $850, 15 percent is $127.50 but the excess over $750 is only $100, so $100 is taken. At $1,250, 15 percent is $187.50 while the excess is $500, so the percentage binds and $187.50 is taken. At $650, the payment sits below the floor and there is no offset at all. The crossover falls at $882.35, where 15 percent of the payment equals the excess over $750.
That crossover is arithmetic, not a figure stated in the text, but it follows directly from the rule. Below it, the dollar floor decides the outcome and the offset grows by a full dollar for each extra dollar of payment above $750. Above it, the percentage decides and the offset grows by 15 cents per dollar. A debt smaller than either number shrinks the offset further, since the debt itself is the first of the three tests.
Which benefits the offset covers and which it skips
The regulation covers payments under the Social Security Act other than Supplemental Security Income, part B of the Black Lung Benefits Act, and payments under laws administered by the Railroad Retirement Board other than tier 2 benefits. SSI is therefore excluded outright, and so is the tier 2 portion of railroad retirement. The rule names no age limit and no hardship test for the floor, which applies by amount alone to every covered payment.
Its reach is also narrower than the headline mechanics suggest. This is Treasury offsetting a benefit to collect another federal agency’s past-due nontax debt, not a private creditor’s claim and not a tax bill. A debt must be delinquent for more than 120 days for purposes of collection under the rule, and the creditor agency, not Treasury, is the party that asked for the offset to be made.
A separate mechanism runs at very different rates. When the Social Security Administration recovers its own overpayment, its overpayment page says the agency will automatically withhold 50% of a benefit, or 10% of an SSI payment, each month until the overpayment is repaid. Mixing the two produces badly wrong expectations in both directions: the Treasury rule never takes half, and the SSA rule has no $750 floor in the Treasury sense.
The regulation also sets a notice duty. Before offsetting a covered payment, the disbursing official must notify the payee in writing of the date offset will commence, naming the type of payment, the creditor agency that requested the offset and a contact point within that agency. The text states no minimum number of days for that notice, so the date the letter gives is the only timing the rule itself guarantees.
What the new student-loan portal leaves out
On September 30, Treasury and the Education Department announced a new online portal that gives Americans with defaulted federal student loans a simpler way to understand their options, address default and return to repayment. The release describes a $1.7 trillion federal student loan portfolio and says more than 5 million borrowers have languished in default for more than six years. It does not mention wage garnishment, Treasury offset, tax refund offset or Social Security offset.
That silence is the practical gap. A defaulted federal student loan is exactly the kind of past-due nontax debt this regulation reaches, and a borrower receiving Social Security retirement or disability benefits has a monthly payment that the lesser-of-three formula governs. The portal announcement describes options and repayment, while the dollar consequence for a benefit check lives in the 2016 text, with its $750 floor and its 15 percent ceiling.
The floor protects a slice of each payment, not the debt. Interest, penalties and administrative costs stay inside the first test, so a balance can persist while the monthly offset stays capped by the percentage or the floor. For a recipient at $850, the regulation fixes the loss at $100 a month; at $1,250, at $187.50. The open question for any given household is which of those two rows its own payment resembles, and the answer sits in the benefit amount on the notice.
Keeping a record when a benefit deposit is reduced
The Bank Account & Debt Protection Kit is written for federal benefit recipients dealing with creditors and collectors, where a deposit arrives smaller than expected and the paperwork behind the reduction is scattered across letters and calls. A Treasury offset notice and a private collector’s demand follow different rules, and the unfinished job is separating them and documenting each.
The Bank Account & Debt Protection Kit is a 10-page kit that includes the 2-month bank protection rule, the debt-validation steps and a protected-funds and dispute log.
Open a protected-funds and dispute log for benefit deposits →
This article was researched and drafted with the assistance of AI and reviewed by The Money Overview editorial team.