Debt buyers that tried to collect long-expired payments on second mortgages from New York homeowners facing foreclosure must pay more than $242,000 in restitution and $240,000 in penalties, Attorney General Letitia James announced Oct. 23, 2026. The companies are also permanently barred from collecting the expired debt. Her office put the combined total at more than $480,000.
Five companies are named: BCMB1 Trust, First Age, LLC, NS194, LLC, Second Start, LLC and Southern MBA Trust, along with their affiliates. The release says they bought more than 3,000 defaulted mortgages in New York starting in 2019, mostly second mortgages written before the 2008 financial crisis.
The practical question for homeowners is who is covered. Anyone in New York who paid one of these companies on an old second mortgage, agreed to a payment plan, or was named in a foreclosure suit seeking years-old payments has records worth gathering. Letters, court papers and bank records showing each payment will matter if the attorney general’s office or a court asks.
Stay ahead of settlement and refund news: Miss an enrollment or claim deadline and the money can be gone. Join the Retirement Money Brief and we’ll send you our Open Settlements & Refund Tracker as a welcome gift.
Get the Brief + the settlements tracker →
We may earn a commission from links on this page.
What the companies did with the old loans
A second mortgage is a loan secured by the same house as the first mortgage, often a home equity loan or a line of credit. When a borrower stopped paying years ago, the original lender frequently wrote the loan off and sold it to a buyer for a fraction of its balance. The buyers named in the release then went to court.
According to the attorney general, the companies filed more than 140 foreclosure lawsuits. Some of those suits demanded the full principal plus interest going back as far as 12 years. That is where the case turned, because the demand reached past what New York law allows.
The release says the demands violated New York’s statute of limitations, which bars collecting past-due payments more than six years old. The state’s civil practice rules, CPLR 213, set a six-year period for actions on a bond or note secured by a mortgage and for actions on a mortgage of real property. A lawsuit filed after that window closes asks a court to enforce a claim the law no longer lets a lender press.
The attorney general calls these loans “zombie” mortgages, because debts the original lender gave up on come back to life when a buyer files suit. Homeowners who thought a second mortgage was finished can be surprised by a foreclosure complaint from a company they never dealt with. The attorney general’s office says the practice put homes at risk.
Restitution, penalties and the end of the demands
The terms break into three parts. The companies owe $240,000 in penalties to the state and more than $242,000 in restitution to consumers who paid or agreed to pay expired debt. They also lose the right to collect it.
The two money figures do different jobs. Penalties are what the companies owe the state for breaking the law, while restitution is meant to return what consumers paid or agreed to pay on debt that could no longer be collected. The release adds the permanent ban on collecting expired debt, which applies to the companies and their affiliates alike.
In foreclosure cases still open, the companies must amend their demands to remove expired debt and drop every demand for expired payments. That keeps homeowners from being asked in court for money the law has already put out of reach.
James said in the release that “no New Yorker should face losing their home to a predatory company demanding mortgage payments that have long since expired.” She added, “I will not tolerate illegal schemes that put New Yorkers’ homes at risk.”
The release does not say how many homeowners will receive restitution, how the payments will be made or when they will go out. It also does not list a deadline or a claim form. The people covered are those who paid or agreed to pay debt the companies were not entitled to collect.
Where a homeowner can take a complaint
The attorney general’s release says anyone who believes they faced an improper foreclosure can file a complaint with the Consumer Frauds and Protection Bureau or call 1-800-771-7755. The office’s complaint page lists the same help line and an online form, and 1-800-788-9898 for callers who are deaf or hard of hearing.
Homeowners with a live foreclosure case have a second need, which is advice on the case itself. A HUD-approved housing counselor, listed through the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, can go through the papers. The CFPB also takes complaints at its own complaint page.
Anyone served with foreclosure papers over an old second mortgage should respond on time and ask a lawyer or a housing counselor about the age of the debt. The date of the last payment is the first fact either will want.
The ruling covers these five companies and their affiliates, so it does not end the practice across the industry. Debt buyers elsewhere hold similar loans, and homeowners can ask who currently owns a second mortgage and how old the last payment was. Those two facts decide whether the six-year clock has run.
Paid a debt buyer on an old second mortgage?
The attorney general has announced the restitution total but not how it will be paid or when. Homeowners who paid these companies over the years are left holding the paperwork, and the detail that decides everything is the date of each payment against the six-year limit.
The Settlement & Refund Recovery System includes a claim log and payment tracker, so each payment made, each letter received and each restitution check expected gets its own line. The scam-proof rules in the same system cover the callers who show up when money is reported to be coming back.
Get the claim log and payment tracker for old mortgage payments →
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.