New York City renters who stored belongings in an Extra Space unit between March 24, 2023, and June 16, 2026, can apply to a $1 million restitution fund created by a settlement with the city’s Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP). Claims close Aug. 1, 2027, or earlier if the fund runs out. Extra Space also agreed to pay more than $700,000 in civil penalties.
Mayor Zohran Mamdani announced the $1.7 million settlement on July 9, 2026, and DCWP opened the fund on Aug. 4. The agency had sued the company in February 2026 after reviewing more than 100 complaints. Extra Space operates about 60 locations in the city. DCWP says its investigation found violations of the New York City Consumer Protection Law, and the lawsuit alleged thousands of them.
What DCWP says Extra Space did
According to the city’s settlement announcement, the company promised clean units while renting ones with vermin, rodent droppings, water damage and mold. It also gave written promises of 30 days’ notice before rate increases, then sharply raised prices after customers moved in. DCWP also describes arbitrary fees, some of which continued after contracts were canceled.
The most serious complaints involved access and auctions. DCWP says Extra Space blocked customers from their units and auctioned belongings without due process when people owed money or fell behind. The agency’s February lawsuit said the company changed locks and threatened auctions unless customers paid unexpected charges, and it sought more than $5 million in penalties.
The settlement requires Extra Space to stop deceptive pricing and condition claims, add due process protections before lockouts or auctions, and give adequate notice before raising prices. It also creates a relocation assistance program. The company’s side of the allegations is not described in the city’s releases.
Which renters can file
DCWP’s claim page lists three situations, and a renter needs to have rented in the city during the window and fit at least one. The first is belongings damaged by rodents, mold, leaks, bugs or other unsafe or unclean conditions. The second is a rent increase within the first six months or an increase of more than 50% during the rental. The third is belongings sold or auctioned without proper notice, or while the renter was disputing an increase or fees. Anyone who fits should find the lease, the rent statements and any photos or emails that show the date and the problem.
Stay ahead of settlement and refund news: Miss an enrollment or claim deadline and the money can be gone. Join the Retirement Money Brief and we’ll send you our Open Settlements & Refund Tracker as a welcome gift.
Get the Brief + the settlements tracker →
We may earn a commission from links on this page.
Fitting one of those situations does not guarantee payment. DCWP says it reviews each claim and decides both eligibility and the amount, and the page does not publish a payout figure. With $1 million set aside for a company with about 60 city locations, the deadline matters less than the phrase “until the fund runs out.”
Commissioner Samuel A.A. Levine put it directly in the release: “This is a PSA for all New Yorkers harmed by Extra Space: there is money on the table for you to claim.” He added that “no one should have to worry about getting ripped off by the company they’ve trusted to store their personal belongings.”
Filing and the gaps in the instructions
The city’s press release tells renters to confirm eligibility and file at nyc.gov/claim-funds, and it also links to the Extra Space settlement page. The claim page offers a Consumer Claim Form in English, Spanish and Simplified Chinese. It does not say how to submit the finished form or what proof DCWP wants, so renters with questions can call 311.
A claim is separate from a complaint. Consumers who want DCWP to look into a facility can file a complaint, with documents if possible, at nyc.gov/Consumers. The two are handled separately.
The outer deadline of Aug. 1, 2027, is more than eight months away, but the fund closes whenever the money is gone. Renters who lost belongings at auction, paid a doubled rent or lived with mold have the most documentation to gather, and the paperwork is easier to find while the lease and bank statements are still within reach.
A license for every storage facility
Under Local Law 171 of 2025, every self-storage facility operating in New York City must hold a DCWP license beginning Aug. 25, 2026. That rule covers Extra Space and every competitor, and it gives the agency a licensing lever over the whole sector rather than a single settlement.
Mayor Mamdani said in announcing the deal that “if you prey on New Yorkers, this administration will hold you accountable.” Deputy Mayor for Economic Justice Julie Su and Levine were also named in the city’s announcement of the settlement.
For renters, the practical split is plain. The restitution fund repays harm from March 2023 through June 2026, and the licensing law and the settlement’s notice rules govern what happens next. Anyone currently renting a unit in the city can compare the lease with the settlement’s rule that the company give adequate notice before raising prices.
Stored belongings with Extra Space in the city?
A restitution fund that closes on Aug. 1, 2027, or whenever the $1 million is gone leaves renters with one real risk: a claim that arrives late or without the lease, rent statements or auction notice that show what happened. The claim page does not say what proof DCWP wants, so the safest file is the fullest one.
The Settlement & Refund Recovery System includes the four-date rule for reading a settlement notice, which separates the deadline from the dates that merely sound like deadlines, and a claim log and payment tracker with a line for each document sent and each reply received.
Its large-print quick-start sheet puts the sequence on one page, which suits a renter sorting a lease, rent bills and photos at the kitchen table.
Get the four-date rule and claim tracker for the Extra Space restitution fund →
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.